Back to homeEconomics and Business Administration · High School Year 3 · Social Sciences · Change subject
Start for free
Prep 3 SS · Economics and Business Administration
Economic reality: a macroeconomic perspective · International trade and the financial system

The balance of payments and the exchange rate

Before you start, make sure you know: Globalization, free trade, and protectionism (High School Year 1 (semesters 1 and 2))

A British tourist stays in Cancún, a company in Monterrey buys German machinery, a family in Oaxaca receives a remittance from the United States. All of those transactions cross the border and are recorded in the balance of payments. On top of that, the price at which pesos are exchanged for dollars, the exchange rate, decides who wins and who loses in each one. Is it good for Mexico when the peso "gets stronger"? We will answer that at the end.

The balance of payments and its three accounts

Diagram of the balance of payments: the current and capital accounts measure whether the country needs financing, and the financial account shows how it is obtained Current account + capital account Surplus: the country lends abroad Deficit: the country needs financing Financial account: how it lends or how it is financed

To classify a transaction, ask yourself two questions. Is something (a good, a service) being bought or sold, or is money being sent without receiving anything in return? That is the current account. Is a financial asset (stocks, bonds, a loan) being bought or sold? That is the financial account. Then work out the direction of the money: if money comes into Mexico it is a receipt, and if it goes out it is a payment.

By accounting, the balance of payments always balances: whatever the country overspends in the current account has to be financed with net capital inflows in the financial account. Put simply:

$$\text{Saldo de cuenta corriente} + \text{cuenta de capital} \approx \text{financiamiento neto con el exterior}$$
Practice★☆☆Not started
Explain what a country's balance of payments records and name its three main accounts (current, capital, and financial), indicating in one sentence what each one records.

Explain what a country's balance of payments records and name its three main accounts (current, capital, and financial), indicating in one sentence what each one records.

Solve
Practice★☆☆Not started
Indicate in which account of the balance of payments each transaction is recorded and whether it is a credit (inflow) or a debit (outflow) for Mexico: a British tourist…

Indicate in which account of the balance of payments each transaction is recorded and whether it is a credit (inflow) or a debit (outflow) for Mexico: a British tourist spends $\$40\,000$ on vacation in Cancún, a Mexican firm buys German machinery, a US fund buys shares in a Mexican bank, and a Mexican emigrant sends money to her family from Germany.

Solve

The current account: goods, services, income, and transfers

Bars with the balances of goods, services, income, and transfers from the example, and the negative total balance of the current account goods −8,000 services −3,000 income −9,000 transf. +11,000 balance −9,000
Practice★★☆Not started
Mexico's current account balance in one year: exports of goods, $800\,000$ million pesos; imports of goods, $1\,100\,000$ million; receipts from services (mainly…

Mexico's current account balance in one year: exports of goods, $800\,000$ million pesos; imports of goods, $1\,100\,000$ million; receipts from services (mainly tourism), $500\,000$ million; payments for services, $200\,000$ million; and net primary and secondary income (rents and transfers), $-40\,000$ million.

  1. a) Calculate the current account balance and state whether there is a surplus or deficit.
  2. b) Explain what this result means and how it is financed (what happens in the financial account?).
Solve

The foreign exchange market and the exchange rate

You always have to check which currency is "the product" and which is "the price." In Mexico the dollar is quoted in pesos: $17.20$ pesos per dollar. In the market for dollars:

  • Those who demand dollars are people who need to pay in dollars: importers, Mexican tourists traveling abroad, Mexican investors who buy assets abroad.

  • Those who supply dollars are people who receive them and want to exchange them for pesos: exporters, foreign tourists in Mexico, people who send remittances, foreign investors who buy in Mexico.

Market for dollars: if the demand for dollars increases, the equilibrium rises and the dollar costs more pesos, that is, the peso depreciates quantity of dollars pesos per dollar demand supply new demand (dotted) E E′

With more Mexican tourists traveling to the United States, the demand for dollars shifts to the right (from E to E′). The dollar costs more pesos and the peso depreciates.

The logic is the same with any other foreign currency. Imagine a foreign currency that is quoted at $1.10$ dollars per unit (this is how the exercises on this page are set up for another country's currency). Here the price is in dollars, so $300$ units of that currency are exchanged for $300 \times 1.10 = 330$ dollars, and $440$ dollars are exchanged for $440 \div 1.10 = 400$ units. If the rate rises to $1.20$ dollars per unit, that currency is worth more dollars: it appreciates against the dollar. The rule is always the same: multiply when you start from the currency whose price is given, and divide when you start from the currency in which the price is expressed.

Practice★☆☆Not started
The figure shows the pesos market against the dollar: on the vertical axis, the exchange rate (dollars per pesos) and, on the horizontal axis, the quantity of pesos…

The figure shows the pesos market against the dollar: on the vertical axis, the exchange rate (dollars per pesos) and, on the horizontal axis, the quantity of pesos traded.

quantity of pesos dollars per pesos demand supply 1.10
  1. a) Read the equilibrium exchange rate from the graph.
  2. b) Explain who demands pesos and who supplies them in this market (think about exporters, importers, and tourists).
Solve

Appreciation and depreciation: effects on exporters and importers

Comparison of effects: a depreciated peso favors exporters and makes imports more expensive; an appreciated peso makes imports cheaper and hurts exporters Peso depreciates exporting is easier importing is more expensive Peso appreciates importing is cheaper exporting is harder

Now a case where the price is quoted in dollars per unit of the exporter's currency. A winery in Parras sells a container of wine for $10{,}000$ dollars. If the currency it is paid in is worth $1.00$ dollar, it receives $10{,}000$ units of that currency. If it appreciates to $1.25$ dollars per unit, divide: $10{,}000 \div 1.25 = 8{,}000$ units. The appreciation of its own currency leaves it with less. The ones who do benefit are importers, who pay less for what they buy abroad, and tourists who travel abroad.

Practice★★☆Not started
The exchange rate of the euro against the dollar is $1.10$ dollars per euro. a) How many dollars do you get when changing $500\ \text{€}$? b) How many euros do you get…

The exchange rate of the euro against the dollar is $1.10$ dollars per euro.

  1. a) How many dollars do you get when changing $500\ \text{€}$?
  2. b) How many euros do you get when changing $770$ dollars?
  3. c) If the rate changes to $1.20$ dollars per euro, has the euro appreciated or depreciated? Explain what this change means.
Solve
Practice★★☆Not started
A winery in Valle de Guadalupe sells wine to the United States at $10,000$ dollars per container. With the exchange rate at $1.00$ dollar per euro, each container yields…

A winery in Valle de Guadalupe sells wine to the United States at $10,000$ dollars per container. With the exchange rate at $1.00$ dollar per euro, each container yields $10,000\ \text{€}$; but the rate rises to $1.25$ dollars per euro.

  1. a) Calculate how many euros it earns now per container.
  2. b) Explain why the appreciation of the euro harms exporters and name two groups that benefit from it instead.
Solve
Practice★★★Not started
An analyst states during a televised debate: "A $10\ \%$ depreciation of the pesos against the dollar is excellent news for the entire Spanish economy: our exports will…

An analyst states during a televised debate: "A $10\ \%$ depreciation of the pesos against the dollar is excellent news for the entire Spanish economy: our exports will soar immediately, and we will correct our trade deficit without any adverse effects".

  1. a) Analytically refute this statement by assessing the disparate impact of this depreciation on two companies: a La Rioja winery that produces using local grapes and sells to the United States, versus a Spanish shipping company whose vessels consume fuel priced in dollars and which has acquired its fleet through bank loans denominated in US currency.
  2. b) Based on the price elasticity of demand for imports and exports, justify why in the short term Spain's trade balance usually deteriorates after a depreciation instead of improving ("J-curve" effect).
  3. c) Predict the effect of this depreciation on the domestic general price level (cost-push or imported inflation) and explain what interest rate policy dilemma the European Central Bank would face if the depreciation coincides with GDP stagnation in the eurozone.
Solve

Interest rates and capital movements

The exchange rate does not depend only on trade. An investor who wants to buy bonds looks for the highest interest rate. If a country raises its interest rate and the others do not, its bonds attract money from abroad.

But a strong currency has consequences. Exported products (such as cars) become more expensive in dollars and sell less, while imports and trips abroad become cheaper. At the same time, a stronger currency makes imported goods cheaper and helps lower inflation, which was the goal of the high rate.

Practice★★★Not started
To control rising inflation, the central bank of Briga raises its interest rates to $5\ \%$, while its trading partners keep theirs at $1.5\ \%$. This differential…

To control rising inflation, the central bank of Briga raises its interest rates to $5\ \%$, while its trading partners keep theirs at $1.5\ \%$. This differential triggers a heavy inflow of foreign financial capital into Brigan public debt.

  1. a) Model the functioning of the foreign exchange market: predict how this flow affects the supply and demand curves for Briga's currency and deduce the resulting change in its nominal exchange rate.
  2. b) Analyze the transmission of this exchange rate change to two key sectors: the Brigan automobile industry (which sells $60\ \%$ of its output abroad) and the domestic hospitality sector catering to foreign travelers.
  3. c) Justify why Briga's Minister of Economy warns that a "too strong" currency can cause deindustrialization and unemployment, even though it makes imports of consumer goods and energy cheaper.
Solve

External imbalances: persistent deficit and crises of confidence

A current account deficit in one year is not a problem. One that lasts for years can be. A deficit is financed with capital inflows: foreign direct investment, bond purchases, loans, or the sale of assets. Every peso that comes in increases what the country owes or what foreigners own in it.

Chain of a crisis of confidence: investors lose confidence, sell bonds, the currency depreciates, and the central bank reacts lose confidence sell bonds the currency depreciates the central bank may raise rates or use international reserves
Practice★★★Not started
The Government of Meridia maintains that an ongoing current account deficit of $4\ \%$ of GDP over a decade is not a cause for concern, arguing that it "reflects the…

The Government of Meridia maintains that an ongoing current account deficit of $4\ \%$ of GDP over a decade is not a cause for concern, arguing that it "reflects the country's attractiveness in drawing funds from the rest of the world". However, the net international investment position (net external debt) already exceeds $75\ \%$ of its GDP.

  1. a) Use the macroeconomic identity of the external balance ($Saving - Investment = Current\ account\ balance$) to refute the official view and explain what this structural deficit reveals about public and private saving patterns in Meridia.
  2. b) Predict what financial and real consequences the country would suffer if an episode of global risk aversion is triggered and international markets abruptly cut off external financing (sudden stop).
  3. c) Design a combination of two economic policy measures (one demand-side fiscal measure and one supply-side structural measure) to balance the external accounts in the medium term, justifying the adjustment costs and sacrifices that each will impose on the population.
Solve

Back to the beginning: is a "strong" peso good for Mexico? It depends. An appreciated peso makes machinery, imported gasoline, and trips abroad cheaper, but it penalizes exporters, tourism, and families that receive remittances. With a depreciated peso the opposite happens. That is why there is no exchange rate that is "good" for everyone.

Summary

See all the exercises in this section