Gene Regulation and Genomes
At school, Yaritza wonders how it is possible that all the cells in her body have the same DNA and yet a neuron and a muscle cell are so different. Having a gene does not mean using it all the time or in every cell. Cells turn genes on and off according to their needs, and they do it at different points along the path DNA → mRNA → protein. On this page you will see how, and how genomes are organized.
Gene Expression Is Differential
A neuron transmits impulses and a muscle cell contracts with force, but both come from the same zygote and have the same DNA. Where is the difference?
It pays to regulate genes because making proteins costs energy and matter: the cell produces only what it needs, when it needs it.
How does the signal reach the genes?
Often the message to turn a gene on comes from outside the cell, for example a hormone. There are two pathways, depending on whether the hormone can cross the membrane or not:
-
Water-soluble hormone (such as adrenaline): it does not cross the membrane. It binds to a membrane receptor (for example, one coupled to a G protein), which triggers a chain of signals inside the cell. It usually changes the activity of enzymes that already exist, so the response is fast and does not require new transcription.
-
Fat-soluble hormone (such as cortisol, a steroid hormone): it crosses the membrane and binds to an intracellular receptor. The hormone-receptor complex enters the nucleus and acts as a transcription factor: it binds to DNA and turns genes on or off. The response is slower and depends on transcription.
All the cells in your body possess the same DNA, yet a neuron and a muscle cell are very different. Explain what causes this difference with reference to gene expression.
All the cells in your body possess the same DNA, yet a neuron and a muscle cell are very different. Explain what causes this difference with reference to gene expression.
What is a constitutive gene and what is a regulated gene? Give an example of each type and explain why it is advantageous for the cell to regulate some of its genes.
What is a constitutive gene and what is a regulated gene? Give an example of each type and explain why it is advantageous for the cell to regulate some of its genes.
What does it mean that a gene is silenced in a cell? Explain one way in which the cell can prevent a given gene from being transcribed.
What does it mean that a gene is silenced in a cell? Explain one way in which the cell can prevent a given gene from being transcribed.
The lac Operon: A Model of Bacterial Regulation
Without lactose, the repressor sticks to the operator and blocks the passage of RNA polymerase. With lactose (the inducer), lactose binds to the repressor and changes its shape: the repressor lets go, the operator is left free, and Z, Y, and A are transcribed.
Mutations and merodiploids: cis and trans
How can we tell whether a bacterium is constitutive because it lacks a repressor (I⁻) or because of a damaged operator (Oᶜ)? Jacob and Monod used merozygotes (partial diploids): bacteria with a second copy of the operon on an F′ plasmid. This way each mutation is tested alongside a normal gene.
-
The repressor is a diffusible protein: it acts in trans. A normal repressor (I⁺) from one copy can block the operator of the other copy. That is why I⁻ is recessive to I⁺.
-
The operator is a DNA sequence: it acts only in cis, on the genes next to it on its own DNA. A mutant operator Oᶜ leaves free only the Z, Y, and A genes of its own copy; the repressor cannot bind to it. That is why Oᶜ is dominant, but only over its neighboring genes.
What is an operon? State in what type of organisms they are found and name the basic components of an inducible operon such as the lac operon.
What is an operon? State in what type of organisms they are found and name the basic components of an inducible operon such as the lac operon.
The diagram represents the lac operon of Escherichia coli in two situations (A and B). State in which of them lactose is present in the medium, name the elements…
The diagram represents the lac operon of Escherichia coli in two situations (A and B). State in which of them lactose is present in the medium, name the elements labelled (P, O, Z-Y-A and ?), and explain what happens to the expression of the structural genes in each situation.
A strain of E. coli grows in a medium with glucose and without lactose. Explain what the state of the lac operon will be under those conditions and describe what will…
A strain of E. coli grows in a medium with glucose and without lactose. Explain what the state of the lac operon will be under those conditions and describe what will happen to the expression of its structural genes when the glucose runs out and lactose is added to the medium.
In a laboratory, a mutant strain of Escherichia coli* displaying a complete deletion in the regulatory gene lacI* (I⁻* phenotype) is studied. A student predicts that…
In a laboratory, a mutant strain of Escherichia coli displaying a complete deletion in the regulatory gene lacI (I⁻ phenotype) is studied. A student predicts that this bacterium will maximally transcribe the structural genes of the lac operon under any circumstance, since the repressor will never bind to the operator.
To test their hypothesis, the strain is cultured in three media with equivalent concentrations of basic nutrients:
-
Medium A: glucose as the sole carbon source.
-
Medium B: simultaneous presence of glucose and lactose.
-
Medium C: lactose as the sole carbon source.
- a) Evaluate whether the student's prediction is correct. Justify what level of operon transcription (null, very low basal, or high) will be observed in each of the three media, detailing the molecular mechanism involved (role of the CAP-cAMP complex and adenylyl cyclase).
- b) Predict with reasoning what would happen to transcription in Medium C if the strain were to acquire a second mutation that inactivated the CAP protein gene.
In haploid bacteria, both a null mutation in the repressor gene (I⁻) and a point mutation in the operator sequence (Oᶜ*) prevent repression of the lac* operon, leading…
In haploid bacteria, both a null mutation in the repressor gene (I⁻) and a point mutation in the operator sequence (Oᶜ) prevent repression of the lac operon, leading to a constitutive phenotype in the absence of lactose.
To discriminate between the two mechanisms, François Jacob and Jacques Monod generated partial diploid strains (merozygotes) using F' plasmids. Analyze the following two strains:
-
Strain 1: I⁺ Oᶜ Z⁺ / I⁺ O⁺ Z⁻
-
Strain 2: I⁺ O⁺ Z⁻ / I⁻ O⁺ Z⁺
(where Z⁺ encodes functional β-galactosidase and Z⁻ a non-functional enzyme).
- a) Predict with reasoning whether active β-galactosidase will be produced in Strain 1 and Strain 2 when cultured in a medium lacking lactose.
- b) Based on your prediction, classify the repressor and the operator as cis-acting or trans-acting regulators, justifying the molecular difference between both types of control.
Regulation in Eukaryotic Cells
In our cells, a sequence located thousands of base pairs from a gene can turn it on. How does it manage to act from that distance?
MicroRNAs are small RNAs that do not code for proteins. They bind by complementarity to an mRNA that has already been formed and degrade it or block its translation.
What is a transcription factor? Explain briefly what role it plays in the regulation of gene expression and to which regions of the DNA it binds.
What is a transcription factor? Explain briefly what role it plays in the regulation of gene expression and to which regions of the DNA it binds.
What is a promoter and what role does it play in the regulation of transcription? Explain what may happen if a mutation disables the promoter of a gene.
What is a promoter and what role does it play in the regulation of transcription? Explain what may happen if a mutation disables the promoter of a gene.
In eukaryotic cells, DNA is packaged bound to histones forming chromatin. Explain how the degree of chromatin compaction influences gene expression.
In eukaryotic cells, DNA is packaged bound to histones forming chromatin. Explain how the degree of chromatin compaction influences gene expression.
In eukaryotic cells there are regulatory sequences called enhancers that can be located thousands of base pairs away from the gene they regulate. Explain how they can…
In eukaryotic cells there are regulatory sequences called enhancers that can be located thousands of base pairs away from the gene they regulate. Explain how they can act over such a distance, referring to the folding of chromatin and to transcription factors.
MicroRNAs are small RNAs that do not encode proteins but regulate gene expression. Explain how they act on the target mRNAs, whether their effect is activating or…
MicroRNAs are small RNAs that do not encode proteins but regulate gene expression. Explain how they act on the target mRNAs, whether their effect is activating or inhibitory, and why they are considered a post-transcriptional level of regulation.
Compare the regulation of gene expression in prokaryotes and in eukaryotes (number of control levels, speed of response to the medium, organisation of the genes) and…
Compare the regulation of gene expression in prokaryotes and in eukaryotes (number of control levels, speed of response to the medium, organisation of the genes) and reason why more possible points of regulation exist in eukaryotic cells.
In an experiment with cultured hepatocytes, the mechanism of action of two hormones is compared: adrenaline (a water-soluble hormone that acts through a G…
In an experiment with cultured hepatocytes, the mechanism of action of two hormones is compared: adrenaline (a water-soluble hormone that acts through a G protein-coupled membrane receptor) and cortisol (a lipid-soluble steroid hormone that binds to an intracellular receptor).
To investigate the signaling pathway, actinomycin D (a potent transcription inhibitor that blocks RNA polymerase II) is added to half of the cultures. Next, the cellular response (enzyme activation and glucose synthesis) is measured over time.
- a) Interpret and justify why the cellular response triggered by adrenaline takes only seconds or minutes to manifest, whereas that of cortisol requires several hours.
- b) Predict how the presence of actinomycin D will affect the response generated by each of the two hormones. Justify your answer at the molecular level.
- c) Explain why, after washing the medium and removing both hormones, the metabolic effects induced by cortisol persist for a much longer time than those of adrenaline.
Epigenetics and Cell Differentiation
Are genes lost? The nuclear transfer experiment
At the end of the 19th century, August Weismann proposed that cells specialize by losing genes: each cell type would keep only the DNA it needs. This could be tested as follows:
-
Gurdon (amphibians, 1962): he took the nucleus from an already differentiated intestinal cell of a tadpole and transferred it into a frog egg whose own nucleus had been removed.
-
Dolly (sheep, 1996): the nucleus of an adult mammary gland cell was used, placed in an egg without a nucleus.
In both cases the egg developed into a complete individual. Conclusion: the nucleus of a differentiated cell keeps all its genes; the cytoplasm of the egg "reprograms" it and reactivates the silenced genes. Weismann was wrong: differentiation depends on which genes are expressed, not on which ones are kept.
In a colorectal carcinoma biopsy, it is detected that the tumor suppressor gene MLH1* is completely silenced, which prevents DNA mismatch repair. When sequencing the…
In a colorectal carcinoma biopsy, it is detected that the tumor suppressor gene MLH1 is completely silenced, which prevents DNA mismatch repair. When sequencing the gene in the tumor, its nucleotide sequence is identical to that of healthy tissue; however, molecular analysis reveals dense hypermethylation of cytosines in CpG islands of its promoter region. When the tumor cells are cultured with 5-azacytidine (a DNA methyltransferase inhibitor), MLH1 expression resumes.
- a) Based on these data, justify why the silencing of MLH1 in this tumor constitutes an epigenetic event and not a genetic mutation.
- b) Explain the physical-molecular mechanism by which the presence of methyl groups on promoter cytosines prevents gene transcription, referring to the binding of transcription factors and chromatin remodeling.
- c) When these 5-azacytidine-treated tumor cells divide in a drug-free medium, new cell generations can inherit the methylation pattern and silence the gene again. Justify how DNA methylation is maintained and transmitted during cell replication by maintenance methyltransferases.
At the end of the 19th century, August Weismann proposed that cell differentiation during embryonic development occurred through a selective and progressive loss of…
At the end of the 19th century, August Weismann proposed that cell differentiation during embryonic development occurred through a selective and progressive loss of genes: each cell lineage would retain only the DNA necessary to perform its specialized function.
- a) Describe the basis of a historic experiment (such as Gurdon's nuclear transfer in amphibians or the cloning of Dolly the sheep) and explain how its results definitively refuted Weismann's hypothesis.
- b) If a neuron and a hepatocyte from the same adult human individual possess exactly the same genome, justify which molecular mechanisms (specific transcription factors and epigenetic modifications such as DNA methylation and histone acetylation) allow each to express a largely different set of proteins and stably maintain its identity.
In Drosophila melanogaster*, the dominant gain-of-function mutation Antennapedia* (Antp*) causes the Antp* gene, whose normal expression is restricted to the second…
In Drosophila melanogaster, the dominant gain-of-function mutation Antennapedia (Antp) causes the Antp gene, whose normal expression is restricted to the second thoracic segment to induce leg development, to be erroneously transcribed in the imaginal discs of the head. As a consequence, the flies develop fully formed legs instead of antennae.
- a) Based on this case, deduce what molecular function the proteins encoded by homeotic (Hox) genes perform, and explain how the activation of a single gene is capable of triggering the coordinated morphogenesis of an entire appendage.
- b) A student puts forward the hypothesis that, if a fly with a homozygous null deletion mutation of Antp (total loss of function) is isolated, the embryo will be born without a head. Refute this hypothesis and predict, with reasoning, what anatomical alteration you would expect to observe in the thorax of said individual.
The Organization of Genomes
The prokaryotic genome is usually a circular DNA in the cytoplasm, without introns, with genes grouped into operons. The eukaryotic genome is in linear chromosomes inside the nucleus, and its genes have exons (which are kept in the mature mRNA) and introns (which are removed during mRNA maturation).
An onion has about $16{,}000$ million base pairs of DNA, five times more than a person (about $3{,}000$ million). Does it need a manual five times more complex?
Go back to the beginning: Yaritza can now answer. Her cells have the same DNA, but each type expresses different genes, thanks to transcription factors, chromatin, and epigenetic marks.
Name two general differences between the genome of a prokaryotic cell and that of a eukaryotic cell (location, DNA shape, presence of introns).
Name two general differences between the genome of a prokaryotic cell and that of a eukaryotic cell (location, DNA shape, presence of introns).
Define intron and exon, and state what happens to each of them during the maturation of the mRNA in eukaryotic cells.
Define intron and exon, and state what happens to each of them during the maturation of the mRNA in eukaryotic cells.
The human genome contains about $20000$ protein-coding genes, but these occupy only a small part of the total DNA. State what other types of sequences the genome…
The human genome contains about $20000$ protein-coding genes, but these occupy only a small part of the total DNA. State what other types of sequences the genome contains and what functions are attributed to some of the non-coding regions.
Only about $1.5\ \%$ of the human genome corresponds to protein-coding sequences. Calculate how many base pairs that percentage is equivalent to in a genome of…
Only about $1.5\ \%$ of the human genome corresponds to protein-coding sequences. Calculate how many base pairs that percentage is equivalent to in a genome of $3 \times 10^9$ base pairs and explain what is known today about the rest of the genome (regulatory sequences, introns, mobile elements, repetitions).
Analyze the following table with genomic data from three representative organisms: | Organism | Genome size (bp) | Estimated no. of genes | Proportion of non-coding DNA…
Analyze the following table with genomic data from three representative organisms:
| Organism | Genome size (bp) | Estimated no. of genes | Proportion of non-coding DNA |
|---|---|---|---|
| Escherichia coli (bacterium) | 4.6 × 10⁶ | 4,300 | ~12 % |
| Homo sapiens (human) | 3.2 × 10⁹ | 21,000 | ~98.5 % |
| Paris japonica (plant) | 1.5 × 10¹¹ | ~30,000 | >99 % |
- a) A student claims that, since Paris japonica has a genome nearly 50 times larger than the human genome, it must possess a proportionally higher biological and anatomical complexity. Refute their claim using the data and explain what the C-value paradox consists of.
- b) In light of the data in the table, explain which types of sequences make up the vast majority of non-coding DNA in eukaryotes and why a bacterium cannot tolerate such a high proportion of non-coding DNA.
Application: Regulation and Genetic Engineering
A case to think about: a team wants E. coli to produce human insulin.
A biotechnology team designs a plasmid so that Escherichia coli* produces recombinant human insulin. In their first trial, they directly cloned the human gene extracted…
A biotechnology team designs a plasmid so that Escherichia coli produces recombinant human insulin. In their first trial, they directly cloned the human gene extracted from nuclear DNA (with its introns and exons) alongside a strong constitutive bacterial promoter. The result was a failure: the cell culture died prematurely due to the toxic accumulation of an anomalous, non-functional protein.
- a) Identify the two fundamental mistakes made in the design and explain the biological and molecular causes of said failure.
- b) Redesign the strategy using the lac operon regulatory system: state what type of nucleic acid they must use as a template for the coding sequence, what indispensable bacterial regulatory elements they must include in the expression vector, and how they will temporally control induction in the fermenter so that the bacteria first reach a high cell density before starting protein synthesis.