Energy Flow
In a mangrove swamp in Samaná Bay, the sun warms the mangrove leaves all day long. If you could follow that energy all the way to a pelican that eats a large fish, you would see something surprising: out of every 1,000 units of energy captured by the mangrove and the algae, only one reaches the pelican. Why is so much energy lost along the way? Understanding this is the key to knowing how an ecosystem works.
Producers and primary production
Two identical rice plots receive the same light, but in the one where it is warmer at night the plants respire faster and accumulate less mass. How do we measure the difference between all the energy a plant makes and the energy that actually remains as new tissue?
The energy that is respired does not disappear: it is used to move molecules, grow, and keep cells alive, and in the end it is dissipated as heat.
Define gross primary production and net primary production, and explain what part of the energy fixed by producers is actually available to herbivores and what part is…
Define gross primary production and net primary production, and explain what part of the energy fixed by producers is actually available to herbivores and what part is used by the plants themselves.
Grasslands fix $12\,000\ \text{kJ/m}^2$ per year as gross primary production, but the plants use $60\ \%$ of it in their own respiration. Calculate the net primary…
Grasslands fix $12\,000\ \text{kJ/m}^2$ per year as gross primary production, but the plants use $60\ \%$ of it in their own respiration. Calculate the net primary production available to the rest of the ecosystem and explain what the respired fraction is used for.
Trophic levels and chains
Example of a chain in a mangrove swamp: mangrove leaf (producer) → crab (primary consumer, herbivore) → snapper (secondary consumer, carnivore) → heron or pelican (tertiary consumer, carnivore).
Another example in a sugarcane field: sugarcane (producer) → rat (primary consumer) → snake (secondary) → hawk (tertiary).
Define trophic level and construct a four-link food chain typical of a Mediterranean holm oak forest, indicating which level each link belongs to and the type of feeding…
Define trophic level and construct a four-link food chain typical of a Mediterranean holm oak forest, indicating which level each link belongs to and the type of feeding of each organism.
Classify these organisms from a dehesa (a Mediterranean wooded pasture) into producers, consumers (indicating their trophic level) and decomposers: holm oak, rabbit,…
Classify these organisms from a dehesa (a Mediterranean wooded pasture) into producers, consumers (indicating their trophic level) and decomposers: holm oak, rabbit, fox, vulture, earthworm and mushroom. Justify each classification.
Distinguish between a food chain and a food web, and explain why ecosystems with highly interconnected webs withstand the disappearance of a species better than those…
Distinguish between a food chain and a food web, and explain why ecosystems with highly interconnected webs withstand the disappearance of a species better than those with simple, linear chains.
Ecological efficiency and the 10% rule
Why is the other 90% lost? Much of the food is not assimilated and leaves in the feces; another part is used in respiration to move, maintain body temperature, and live; and another part stays in uneaten parts (bones, hair, roots). All of that ends up dissipated as heat or in the decomposers.
In a meadow, producers fix $20\,000\ \text{kcal/m}^2$ per year and herbivores assimilate $2\,000\ \text{kcal/m}^2$ over the same period. Calculate the ecological…
In a meadow, producers fix $20\,000\ \text{kcal/m}^2$ per year and herbivores assimilate $2\,000\ \text{kcal/m}^2$ over the same period. Calculate the ecological efficiency of this transfer, expressed as a percentage.
In an ecosystem, producers fix $15\,000\ \text{kJ/m}^2$ per year, herbivores assimilate $1\,500\ \text{kJ/m}^2$ and carnivores $120\ \text{kJ/m}^2$ over the same period.…
In an ecosystem, producers fix $15\,000\ \text{kJ/m}^2$ per year, herbivores assimilate $1\,500\ \text{kJ/m}^2$ and carnivores $120\ \text{kJ/m}^2$ over the same period. Calculate the ecological efficiency of each transfer and comment on whether they fit the general rule.
An aquatic ecosystem shows these annual energy values per level: producers, $50\,000\ \text{kJ}$; herbivores, $4\,800\ \text{kJ}$; carnivores, $450\ \text{kJ}$.…
An aquatic ecosystem shows these annual energy values per level: producers, $50\,000\ \text{kJ}$; herbivores, $4\,800\ \text{kJ}$; carnivores, $450\ \text{kJ}$. Calculate the efficiency of each transfer and comment on whether they comply with the $10\ \%$ rule.
The following annual data are known for a steppe ecosystem: producers, $10\,000\ \text{kJ/m}^2$; herbivores, $1\,200\ \text{kJ/m}^2$; carnivores, $60\ \text{kJ/m}^2$.…
The following annual data are known for a steppe ecosystem: producers, $10\,000\ \text{kJ/m}^2$; herbivores, $1\,200\ \text{kJ/m}^2$; carnivores, $60\ \text{kJ/m}^2$. Calculate the efficiency of each transfer and explain why the second is much lower, considering the digestibility of the diet and the carnivores' expenditure on activity.
The energy pyramid
This explains why food chains rarely go beyond four or five links: by the time you reach the top, so little energy is left that it cannot sustain a population.
Explain, using the concept of ecological efficiency, why ecosystem food chains rarely have more than four or five levels.
Explain, using the concept of ecological efficiency, why ecosystem food chains rarely have more than four or five levels.
Look at the energy pyramid in the diagram: a) Identify which trophic level each tier (A, B, C, and D) occupies. b) Calculate the missing value at level D ($?$) assuming…
Look at the energy pyramid in the diagram:
- a) Identify which trophic level each tier (A, B, C, and D) occupies.
- b) Calculate the missing value at level D ($?$) assuming that all transfers have the same efficiency as the first one.
Biomass: biomass pyramids and pyramids of numbers
The biomass of a trophic level is the mass of living matter (in grams or kilograms per square meter) at that level. In most terrestrial ecosystems it decreases as you go up a level, because each level receives little energy from the one below it and can therefore support less mass.
In a sample of open seawater, $4\ \text{g/m}^3$ of phytoplankton and $12\ \text{g/m}^3$ of the zooplankton that feeds on it are recorded. How can so little producer support three times as much mass of consumers?
Explain what the biomass of a trophic level is and why, in most terrestrial ecosystems, total biomass decreases as you move up the food chain.
Explain what the biomass of a trophic level is and why, in most terrestrial ecosystems, total biomass decreases as you move up the food chain.
Differentiate between ecological pyramids of energy, biomass, and numbers. Explain in which situation a biomass pyramid can appear inverted (give a marine example) and…
Differentiate between ecological pyramids of energy, biomass, and numbers. Explain in which situation a biomass pyramid can appear inverted (give a marine example) and why an energy pyramid is never inverted.
In a holm oak forest, a single holm oak can feed thousands of caterpillars, and these in turn dozens of tits. Describe in words the resulting pyramid of numbers, explain…
In a holm oak forest, a single holm oak can feed thousands of caterpillars, and these in turn dozens of tits. Describe in words the resulting pyramid of numbers, explain why it appears "inverted" at its base, and discuss whether the biomass pyramid of that same holm oak forest would also be inverted.
You can do it on paper and send a photo with your answer.
Compare the biomass pyramid of a grassland with that of an oceanic phytoplankton zone: a) explain why the oceanic pyramid can be inverted at a given instant whereas the…
Compare the biomass pyramid of a grassland with that of an oceanic phytoplankton zone: a) explain why the oceanic pyramid can be inverted at a given instant whereas the grassland one is not; b) discuss which property of phytoplankton (its enormous reproduction rate) makes this possible; c) explain why the energy pyramid of that same ocean, in contrast, is always upright.
Open energy flow and the cycling of matter
Why can't energy be recycled? Each time it is used for biological work, part of it is turned into heat, and dispersed heat cannot be used again by plants, which can only capture light. Decomposers return minerals to the soil, but not energy.
Flows between ecosystems also connect matter and energy. Pelicans and other seabirds feed at sea and leave their guano on islands and coasts: in this way they carry nutrients (phosphorus, nitrogen) from the marine ecosystem to the terrestrial one, and act as "vectors" linking both systems.
Explain, using the concepts of useful energy and dissipated heat, why energy passes through the ecosystem in one direction only (an open flow) whereas matter can…
Explain, using the concepts of useful energy and dissipated heat, why energy passes through the ecosystem in one direction only (an open flow) whereas matter can circulate over and over again (a closed cycle).
Seabird colonies accumulate guano on the islands where they breed. Explain what flow of matter and energy this guano represents between the marine and the terrestrial…
Seabird colonies accumulate guano on the islands where they breed. Explain what flow of matter and energy this guano represents between the marine and the terrestrial ecosystems, and what role the birds play as "vectors" connecting both systems.
These annual flows are measured in a lake: producers, $8\,000\ \text{kJ/m}^2$; herbivores, $900\ \text{kJ/m}^2$; carnivores, $110\ \text{kJ/m}^2$; in addition,…
These annual flows are measured in a lake: producers, $8\,000\ \text{kJ/m}^2$; herbivores, $900\ \text{kJ/m}^2$; carnivores, $110\ \text{kJ/m}^2$; in addition, decomposers receive $3\,000\ \text{kJ/m}^2$ of remains from all levels. a) Calculate the efficiency of the two transfers between levels. b) Explain what role decomposers play in the lake's energy balance. c) Predict what would happen to the nutrient cycle and to the trophic levels if decomposers disappeared.
Applications: productivity, trophic cascades, and diet
Net primary productivity is the NPP per unit of area and time. It depends on limiting abiotic factors: in a dry forest, water is the main factor; in the open sea, far from the coast, the scarcity of nutrients such as nitrogen and phosphorus is, even though there is light.
A trophic cascade occurs when changing one level alters the others. If overfishing removes the large predators from a reef, the medium-sized fish that feed on herbivores increase, the herbivores decrease, and the algae grow out of control over the coral.
The advice "eat from low trophic levels" has a basis in energy flow, but with some caveats: a low-level species may be overexploited (some small fish), and livestock that graze on land unsuitable for farming make use of land that would not produce plant food. In addition to trophic level, water use, transportation, fertilizers, and deforestation also matter.
A holm oak forest and an open ocean area far from the coast have very different net primary productivities. Explain what net primary productivity is and explain the…
A holm oak forest and an open ocean area far from the coast have very different net primary productivities. Explain what net primary productivity is and explain the abiotic factors that limit it in each of these two ecosystems.
Overfishing eliminates large predatory fish from a coastal area. Predict what will happen to the immediately lower trophic levels and explain how this 'trophic cascade'…
Overfishing eliminates large predatory fish from a coastal area. Predict what will happen to the immediately lower trophic levels and explain how this 'trophic cascade' can end up affecting even the seabed algae.
Assuming an ecological efficiency of $10\ \%$ in each transfer, calculate how many kilograms of producers are needed to generate $1\ \text{kg}$ of biomass of a predator…
Assuming an ecological efficiency of $10\ \%$ in each transfer, calculate how many kilograms of producers are needed to generate $1\ \text{kg}$ of biomass of a predator situated at the fourth trophic level of a chain. Comment on what the result implies for the conservation of large predators.
Trout are introduced into a high-mountain lake that had no fish and hosted abundant amphibians and large planktonic crustaceans. a) Predict what will happen to the…
Trout are introduced into a high-mountain lake that had no fish and hosted abundant amphibians and large planktonic crustaceans. a) Predict what will happen to the amphibian and zooplankton populations. b) Explain how the change in zooplankton can affect the phytoplankton and the clarity of the water (a trophic cascade). c) Argue what should be done from an environmental management point of view and why these recreational introductions were common practice for decades.
A crop field fixes $20\,000\ \text{kJ/m}^2$ per year. a) Assuming an efficiency of $10\ \%$ per transfer, calculate how many $\text{kJ}$ remain as chicken meat after one…
A crop field fixes $20\,000\ \text{kJ/m}^2$ per year. a) Assuming an efficiency of $10\ \%$ per transfer, calculate how many $\text{kJ}$ remain as chicken meat after one transfer (from crop to chicken) and what area is needed to obtain $2\,000\ \text{kJ}$ of that meat. b) Calculate the area needed to obtain those same $2\,000\ \text{kJ}$ by eating the crop directly. c) Comment on what the comparison implies for feeding the world population.
The phrase "eat from low trophic levels" is used as environmental advice. Analyse it scientifically: what basis it has in terms of energy flow, what nuances should be…
The phrase "eat from low trophic levels" is used as environmental advice. Analyse it scientifically: what basis it has in terms of energy flow, what nuances should be added (fishing for low-level but overexploited species, livestock grazing on dehesas unsuitable for cultivation) and what other factors, besides trophic level, determine the impact of a food.
Back to the beginning: the pelican receives only 1 out of every 1,000 units of energy because it is in the fourth level (mangrove → crab → snapper → pelican): $1{,}000 \times 0.10 \times 0.10 \times 0.10 = 1$ unit.