Back to homeTechnology · 4th ESO A · Change subject
Start for free
ESO Y4A · Technology
Computational thinking and robotics · Control systems

Open loop and closed loop

A fan runs for as long as you decide; an air conditioner switches itself off only once the room is at the temperature you asked for. Both are automatic, but only the second checks its own result. That check has a name: feedback.

Before you start, make sure you know: Control systems (3rd ESO)
Before you start, make sure you know: Operations with integers (1st ESO)

The block diagram of a control system

In its simplest form, a control block receives a setpoint (the value you want to achieve) and generates a control signal that acts on the process (what you want to control), producing an output.

Basic block diagram of a control system: the setpoint enters the controller, which sends the control signal to the process, and the process produces the output. setpoint controller decides the control signal control signal process what you want to control output
Practice★☆☆Not started
In your own words, explain what an open-loop control system and a closed-loop control system are, and give an everyday example of each other than a thermostat.

In your own words, explain what an open-loop control system and a closed-loop control system are, and give an everyday example of each other than a thermostat.

Solve
Practice★☆☆Not started
Define what the setpoint (reference value) of a control system is, and state the typical setpoint for each of these three systems: home heating, a car's cruise control,…

Define what the setpoint (reference value) of a control system is, and state the typical setpoint for each of these three systems: home heating, a car's cruise control, and a refrigerator.

Solve

Open loop: acting without checking

Block diagram of an open-loop system: the setpoint enters the controller, which sends the control signal to the process, and the process produces the output, with no path back to the controller. setpoint control signal output controller process
Practice★☆☆Not started
The figure shows the block diagram of a closed-loop system, but the name of the signal returning from the sensor to the summing junction (marked with "?") is missing. a)…

The figure shows the block diagram of a closed-loop system, but the name of the signal returning from the sensor to the summing junction (marked with "?") is missing.

Block diagram of a closed-loop control system Setpoint + − Controller Actuator Process Output Sensor ?
  1. a) State the name of that signal.
  2. b) Explain what information it carries and what it is used for.
Solve
Practice★☆☆Not started
Match each term with its definition: (a) setpoint, (b) error, (c) feedback, (d) output. Definitions: (1) value to be maintained; (2) difference between the desired value…

Match each term with its definition: (a) setpoint, (b) error, (c) feedback, (d) output. Definitions: (1) value to be maintained; (2) difference between the desired value and the actual value; (3) information about the actual state that returns to the input; (4) quantity controlled by the system.

Solve
Practice★★☆Not started
A thermostat is set to a setpoint of $22\ ^\circ\text{C}$ and the room is at $19\ ^\circ\text{C}$. Calculate the error measured by the comparator and describe what the…

A thermostat is set to a setpoint of $22\ ^\circ\text{C}$ and the room is at $19\ ^\circ\text{C}$. Calculate the error measured by the comparator and describe what the system does until the error becomes zero.

Solve

Closed loop: error and feedback

Block diagram of a closed-loop system: the setpoint enters a comparator, which subtracts the output measured by the sensor and sends the error to the controller; the controller acts on the process, whose output returns to the comparator through the feedback. setpoint + + − error controller process output feedback (sensor)
Practice★★☆Not started
In a tank, a float connected to a valve shuts off the water inlet upon reaching the desired level. Identify the setpoint, sensor, comparator, actuator, and controlled…

In a tank, a float connected to a valve shuts off the water inlet upon reaching the desired level. Identify the setpoint, sensor, comparator, actuator, and controlled variable in this system.

Solve
Practice★★☆Not started
The figure shows the control loop for a car's cruise control, with the setpoint and actual speed shown. Calculate the missing error value, identify which physical…

The figure shows the control loop for a car's cruise control, with the setpoint and actual speed shown. Calculate the missing error value, identify which physical component acts as the sensor and which as the actuator, and explain what command the controller will give.

Setpoint 100 km/h + − error = ? Controller Motor and wheels actual speed 92 km/h Speedometer
Solve
Practice★★☆Not started
Create a comparison table between a ceiling fan (open loop) and an air conditioner (closed loop), listing two advantages and two disadvantages for each, considering…

Create a comparison table between a ceiling fan (open loop) and an air conditioner (closed loop), listing two advantages and two disadvantages for each, considering precision, cost, and electricity consumption.

Solve

Disturbances and why closed loop is more robust

An open-loop system has no way of reacting to a disturbance: it carries on doing what it was programmed to do, whether that works or not. A closed-loop system detects the disturbance as a change in the measured output, turns it into an error and corrects it: that is why it is said to be more robust in the face of the unexpected.

Practice★★★Not started
Look at the level control mechanism in the figure. It is desired for the water to stabilize at a higher level than the current one without replacing any parts. a)…

Look at the level control mechanism in the figure. It is desired for the water to stabilize at a higher level than the current one without replacing any parts.

  1. a) Analyze the role of the pivoting lever (marked with "?"): justify how it physically performs the function of a comparator between the setpoint and the actual measurement.
  2. b) Design and justify two possible mechanical adjustments in the mechanism (on the rod, the float, or the pivot point) to raise the desired filling level.
  3. c) Predict what will happen to the water level if the tank suffers a constant leak through the bottom that is smaller than the maximum inflow rate (disturbance): will it empty, reach the desired level exactly, or stabilize slightly below it? Justify your answer in terms of error and feedback.
water inlet desired level ?
Solve
Practice★★★Not started
A vehicle drives with cruise control set at $100\ \text{km/h}$. When starting to climb a steep slope, its speed drops to $92\ \text{km/h}$, takes $5\ \text{s}$ to return…

A vehicle drives with cruise control set at $100\ \text{km/h}$. When starting to climb a steep slope, its speed drops to $92\ \text{km/h}$, takes $5\ \text{s}$ to return to $100\ \text{km/h}$, and even momentarily reaches $102\ \text{km/h}$ before stabilizing. A driver states: "The system does not work properly; if it were an effective closed loop, the speed would never have dropped below $100\ \text{km/h}$ nor would it have overshot later."

  1. a) Refute the driver's statement by explaining why it is physically impossible for the correction to a disturbance to be instantaneous, identifying the limitations of the actuator and the process.
  2. b) Analyze the evolution of the error ($e = v_{\text{setpoint}} - v_{\text{actual}}$): indicate its sign and how it varies at the three key moments (during the drop to $92\ \text{km/h}$, when crossing $100\ \text{km/h}$, and during the peak of $102\ \text{km/h}$).
  3. c) Justify what causes this overshoot of $102\ \text{km/h}$ in terms of the vehicle's inertia and the loop's response time.
Solve
Practice★★★Not started
You are tasked with automating the filling of a swimming pool so that the water stays between two marks: a minimum level of $1,40\ \text{m}$ and a maximum level of…

You are tasked with automating the filling of a swimming pool so that the water stays between two marks: a minimum level of $1,40\ \text{m}$ and a maximum level of $1,50\ \text{m}$.

  1. a) Justify why a design with a single level sensor that activates the electric pump as soon as the water drops below $1,50\ \text{m}$ would cause premature motor breakdowns due to waves caused by wind or swimmers.
  2. b) Design the appropriate control loop: specify what type of sensors you would use (on/off type with hysteresis or two independent sensors), what the actuator is, and develop the logic rule or decision table that the controller must follow to turn the pump on and off.
  3. c) Analyze two external disturbances of opposite sign (one that increases the level and another that reduces it) and describe how the system will react to each to protect the facility.
Solve

Summary

See all the exercises in this section