Electric and magnetic field lines
A field-line map is a drawing worth more than a thousand equations: at a glance it tells you which way the field points at each position and where it is strongest. Think of the compass in your phone's maps app or a hiker's compass in Yellowstone: both work because of the Earth's magnetic field lines. But electric and magnetic field lines differ in a fundamental way that is tied to one of the oldest open questions in physics: do magnetic monopoles exist?
What field lines are and their rules
Sprinkle iron filings on a sheet of paper placed over a magnet and tap it gently: the metal specks immediately arrange themselves into continuous arcs joining the ends. A small compass placed on the paper does the same job: its needle always aligns along the field line passing through its position. How can we describe with geometric precision that invisible map that guides the orientation of each filing?
Lines of point charges
Electric field lines point away from a positive charge and toward a negative charge. Close to the charge the lines are crowded together; as you move away they spread out, so the field gets weaker (it falls as $1/r^2$). The number of lines drawn leaving or entering a charge is proportional to the size of the charge: a charge $+2q$ gets twice as many lines as $-q$. Any lines that do not end on a nearby negative charge continue off to infinity or to other negative charges far away.
State which of the following statements about electric field lines are true and which are false, correcting the false ones: a) They start on positive charges and end on…
State which of the following statements about electric field lines are true and which are false, correcting the false ones:
- a) They start on positive charges and end on negative charges.
- b) They can cross each other if the charges are sufficiently large.
- c) Where they are closer together, the field is stronger.
- d) The electric field vector at each point is tangent to the field line passing through it.
a) Draw in your notebook the field lines of a positive point charge and, separately, those of a negative point charge, indicating with arrows the direction in each case.…
- a) Draw in your notebook the field lines of a positive point charge and, separately, those of a negative point charge, indicating with arrows the direction in each case.
- b) Explain how the spacing between the lines changes as you move away from the charge and what this indicates about the field strength.
You can do it on paper and send a photo with your answer.
On a magnetic field line map, the lines appear very close together in one area and far apart in another. Look at the map: a) Where is the field most intense? Justify…
On a magnetic field line map, the lines appear very close together in one area and far apart in another. Look at the map:
- a) Where is the field most intense? Justify your answer.
- b) If a small compass is placed at any point on the map, how will it align itself relative to the line passing through that point?
When drawing field maps, the number of lines starting or ending at a charge is taken to be proportional to its value. Two point charges, $+2\times q$ and $-q$, are close…
When drawing field maps, the number of lines starting or ending at a charge is taken to be proportional to its value. Two point charges, $+2\times q$ and $-q$, are close together.
- a) How many lines leave the positive charge for every line that ends on the negative charge?
- b) If all the lines ending on the negative charge come from the positive charge, what happens to the "surplus" lines from the positive charge?
- c) Qualitatively draw the map in your notebook.
You can do it on paper and send a photo with your answer.
Magnetic field lines are always closed
Earth as a giant magnet
The Earth's field looks like that of a bar magnet tilted slightly from the rotation axis. The north end of a compass needle is attracted to the pole near geographic north, so that region is actually a magnetic south pole. Field lines enter the Earth there, so in the Northern Hemisphere they point down into the ground (a vertical component) as well as north (a horizontal component). Near the equator they are nearly horizontal.
Shielding
A metal box (Faraday cage) blocks static electric fields: charges in the metal shift until they cancel the field inside. There are no magnetic charges that can shift, so a plain conducting box does not block a static magnetic field. Magnetic shielding uses high-permeability iron-nickel alloys that guide the closed lines through the material and around the protected space.
Magnetic field lines, unlike electric field lines, are always closed loops. a) Describe the path they follow in a bar magnet: where they emerge, where they enter, and…
Magnetic field lines, unlike electric field lines, are always closed loops.
- a) Describe the path they follow in a bar magnet: where they emerge, where they enter, and what they do inside the magnet.
- b) Using the above, explain why breaking a magnet in half does not yield an isolated north pole and south pole, but rather two complete magnets.
Summarize in two or three sentences the fundamental difference between electric field lines and magnetic field lines in terms of where they begin and end, and relate it…
Summarize in two or three sentences the fundamental difference between electric field lines and magnetic field lines in terms of where they begin and end, and relate it to these two facts: isolated electric charges (positive or negative) do exist, and isolated magnetic poles have not been observed.
a) Draw in your notebook the field lines of a bar magnet, showing the north and south poles and the direction of the lines, both outside and inside the magnet. b) State…
- a) Draw in your notebook the field lines of a bar magnet, showing the north and south poles and the direction of the lines, both outside and inside the magnet.
- b) State in which areas of the drawing the lines are closest together and explain what this means regarding the field at the poles.
You can do it on paper and send a photo with your answer.
Below are three separate maps of magnetic field lines: that of a current-carrying loop (seen edge-on), that of a short solenoid and that of a bar magnet. For simplicity,…
Below are three separate maps of magnetic field lines: that of a current-carrying loop (seen edge-on), that of a short solenoid and that of a bar magnet. For simplicity, the arrows showing the direction of the lines have been omitted from the maps, and the direction of the current is not shown.
- a) Explain how the three maps are similar.
- b) Why is a current-carrying loop said to behave like a small magnet?
- c) If the current in the loop is counterclockwise when viewed from one of its faces, does that face act as a north pole or as a south pole? Justify your answer using the right-hand rule.
The Earth's magnetic field resembles that of a giant bar magnet, slightly tilted relative to the Earth's axis of rotation. a) Draw in your notebook, qualitatively, the…
The Earth's magnetic field resembles that of a giant bar magnet, slightly tilted relative to the Earth's axis of rotation.
- a) Draw in your notebook, qualitatively, the lines of the Earth's magnetic field around the planet.
- b) A compass points with its north end toward geographic north: explain why this means that near geographic north there is actually a magnetic south pole.
- c) Bearing in mind that field lines enter through the magnetic south pole, do they enter or leave the ground in the Northern Hemisphere? What components does the Earth's field have there: horizontal, vertical, or both?
You can do it on paper and send a photo with your answer.
Lines created by currents
What you saw earlier about wires, loops and solenoids can now be reread in terms of field lines. The direction of the lines comes from the right-hand rule: point your thumb along the current, and your fingers curl the way the lines go. Around a wire the lines are concentric circles, lines pass through a loop as if it were a small magnet with a north pole on one face and a south pole on the other, and there is a nearly parallel, uniform bundle inside a solenoid that looks a lot like that of a bar magnet.
Capacitor and solenoid compared
A parallel-plate capacitor and a long solenoid both give a nearly uniform field inside and almost none outside. The differences matter: the capacitor's electric lines are open, starting on the positive plate and ending on the negative plate, with charges as sources. The solenoid's magnetic lines are closed loops that continue outside and return around the coil, and the source is moving charge (current). In real devices, both fields bulge outward at the edges (edge effects).
An upward current flows through a straight vertical wire. a) Draw in your notebook, in a horizontal plane perpendicular to the wire, the lines of its magnetic field:…
An upward current flows through a straight vertical wire.
- a) Draw in your notebook, in a horizontal plane perpendicular to the wire, the lines of its magnetic field: indicate their shape, their direction (right-hand rule), and how their spacing changes with distance from the wire.
- b) Relate this increasing spacing to the dependence $B = \frac{\mu_0\times I}{2\pi\times r}$.
You can do it on paper and send a photo with your answer.
In Oersted's experiment (1820) it was observed for the first time that an electric current deflects a nearby compass needle. The setup is shown in the figure (top view).…
In Oersted's experiment (1820) it was observed for the first time that an electric current deflects a nearby compass needle. The setup is shown in the figure (top view).
- a) What did this observation demonstrate about the relationship between electricity and magnetism?
- b) The needle tends to align perpendicular to the wire: what shape must the lines of the magnetic field created by the current have, then? Justify your answer.
The magnetic field lines of a straight wire are concentric circles that get farther apart as they move away from the wire. a) Draw the situation in your notebook, with…
The magnetic field lines of a straight wire are concentric circles that get farther apart as they move away from the wire.
- a) Draw the situation in your notebook, with the current coming out of the page.
- b) Using $B = \frac{\mu_0\times I}{2\pi\times r}$, calculate the ratios $\frac{B(r)}{B(2\times r)}$ and $\frac{B(r)}{B(3\times r)}$ and explain why the lines should be drawn farther and farther apart.
- c) How should a uniform magnetic field be drawn using this same line convention?
You can do it on paper and send a photo with your answer.
a) Draw in your notebook the field line map of a current-carrying solenoid, both inside and outside. b) Explain, based on your drawing, why the inner field is much more…
- a) Draw in your notebook the field line map of a current-carrying solenoid, both inside and outside.
- b) Explain, based on your drawing, why the inner field is much more intense and almost uniform, whereas the outer field is weak.
- c) Compare the outer map with that of a bar magnet: what similarity do you observe?
You can do it on paper and send a photo with your answer.
An ideal parallel-plate capacitor and an ideal long solenoid both generate a practically uniform field in their interior and an almost zero field outside. a) Draw in…
An ideal parallel-plate capacitor and an ideal long solenoid both generate a practically uniform field in their interior and an almost zero field outside.
- a) Draw in your notebook, side by side, the field line maps of both devices.
- b) Point out the similarities between both maps: interior uniformity, negligible outer field.
- c) Point out the fundamental differences: what are the "sources" of the field in each case? Are the lines open or closed? What happens at the edges in real devices (edge effects)?
You can do it on paper and send a photo with your answer.
Superposition of maps and neutral points
If you place two identical magnets facing each other by their north poles and slide a small compass between them, there is an exact central point where the needle becomes disoriented and points nowhere. Why does the magnetic force vanish at that particular point in space?
A flat loop in a uniform field is crossed by the maximum number of lines when its plane is perpendicular to the field, and by none when it is parallel to it. This idea, how many lines pass through a surface, is the magnetic flux you will study in the unit on induction.
Electric dipole
An electric dipole is a $+q$ and a $-q$ close together. Lines leave the positive charge and curve around to end on the negative one. Outside, the map looks like a bar magnet's, but the lines are open: they stop on the charges. A magnet's lines continue through the magnet and close.
Two identical positive charges $+q$ are close to each other. a) Qualitatively draw in your notebook the field line map of the system. b) Locate the point where the total…
Two identical positive charges $+q$ are close to each other.
- a) Qualitatively draw in your notebook the field line map of the system.
- b) Locate the point where the total electric field is zero and justify it by symmetry.
- c) Reason why no line leaving one of the charges ends on the other.
You can do it on paper and send a photo with your answer.
a) Draw in your notebook the field line map of an electric dipole (a $+q$ charge and a $-q$ charge close together). b) Separately, draw the field line map of a bar…
- a) Draw in your notebook the field line map of an electric dipole (a $+q$ charge and a $-q$ charge close together).
- b) Separately, draw the field line map of a bar magnet.
- c) Compare both maps: how are they similar on the outside? How do they fundamentally differ, considering whether the lines form closed loops or not and what happens in the region between the poles?
You can do it on paper and send a photo with your answer.
Two identical bar magnets are placed on a table with their north poles facing each other. Look at the setup: a) Qualitatively draw in your notebook the field line map in…
Two identical bar magnets are placed on a table with their north poles facing each other. Look at the setup:
- a) Qualitatively draw in your notebook the field line map in the region between both magnets.
- b) Locate the neutral point (point of zero field) and justify it by superposition of the fields from each magnet.
- c) Repeat the analysis when a north pole and a south pole face each other: is there a neutral point between them now? What are the lines like in the intermediate region and what does this imply about the force between the magnets in each case?
You can do it on paper and send a photo with your answer.
Line density and curvature of paths
In photographs from a bubble chamber, the tracks of charged particles curve into tighter and tighter spirals as the particles slow down. What visual relationship is there between the spacing of the field lines and how easily a charge bends?
Prove by contradiction that two field lines (electric or magnetic) can never cross. The assumed situation is shown in the figure: a) Suppose two lines intersect at a…
Prove by contradiction that two field lines (electric or magnetic) can never cross. The assumed situation is shown in the figure:
- a) Suppose two lines intersect at a point and draw in your notebook the tangents to both at that point.
- b) Recall what relationship the tangent to a line has with the field vector at each point: how many distinct field vectors would there be then at the intersection point?
- c) Conclude why this situation is impossible and state the resulting property.
You can do it on paper and send a photo with your answer.
A Faraday cage (a cavity surrounded by conducting material) cancels out the external electric field inside it, because the charges in the conductor redistribute until…
A Faraday cage (a cavity surrounded by conducting material) cancels out the external electric field inside it, because the charges in the conductor redistribute until they compensate for it.
- a) Explain, using this mechanism, why the cage works with static electric fields.
- b) Reason, from the fact that magnetic field lines are closed loops and there are no "magnetic charges" that can redistribute, why a conducting cage does not shield a static magnetic field.
- c) Real magnetic shielding uses high-permeability ferromagnetic materials, which "channel" the field lines through their interior. Relate this to the fact that field lines cannot simply terminate.
Back to the beginning: To date no experiment has detected isolated magnetic monopoles; that is why magnetic field lines have no point sources or sinks and always form continuous, closed curves.