Gravitational, Electric, and Magnetic Phenomena
A magnet pulls a paper clip toward it before touching it. When you take a shirt out of the dryer, the socks stay stuck to it. A mango falls from the tree without anyone pushing it. All three are forces that act without contact, but they are not the same force. How many forces of nature are behind these phenomena, and how do they differ?
The gravitational force
You drop an eraser and a book at the same time and both fall to the floor. The Moon, on the other hand, does not fall: it orbits around the Earth. What common cause is behind all of this?
Gravity acts at a distance: the Earth does not need to touch the mango to make it fall. Also, it only attracts, never repels.
Mass and weight
That is why the astronauts bounced along in little hops on the Moon: with the same push, the weak gravity lets them go higher and take longer to come down.
You drop your sandwich and it lands on the floor. What force brought it down there? Did anything need to touch it or push it down? What are forces that act without…
You drop your sandwich and it lands on the floor. What force brought it down there? Did anything need to touch it or push it down? What are forces that act without contact called?
A $1\ \text{kg}$ kitchen weight travels to the Moon. a) Does it still have a mass of $1\ \text{kg}$ there? b) Does it weigh the same on the Moon as on Earth? c) Explain…
A $1\ \text{kg}$ kitchen weight travels to the Moon.
- a) Does it still have a mass of $1\ \text{kg}$ there?
- b) Does it weigh the same on the Moon as on Earth?
- c) Explain in your own words the difference between mass and weight.
On the surface of Mars, gravity is about $3$ times weaker than on Earth. a) If you weigh $450\ \text{N}$ on Earth, how much would you weigh on Mars? b) Would your mass…
On the surface of Mars, gravity is about $3$ times weaker than on Earth.
- a) If you weigh $450\ \text{N}$ on Earth, how much would you weigh on Mars?
- b) Would your mass have changed? Justify your answer.
- c) Would it be easier or harder to lift your rucksack there? Why?
The electric force
If you rub a plastic pen on your shirt and bring it close to small pieces of paper, they jump up and stick to it. Why does that force appear when you rub?
The hair is attracted even though it is not charged: the balloon's negative charge rearranges the charges in the hair, so the positive ones end up closer to the balloon and the negative ones farther away. The attraction of the nearby charges beats the repulsion of the distant ones, and the hair moves toward the balloon. The effect weakens over time because the charges gradually escape into the air and into your hands, especially on a humid day.
Lightning
In a storm, charges separate in the clouds and a bolt of lightning strikes: it is an enormous electric discharge. Tall metal points connected to the ground (lightning rods) give the discharge an easy path to the earth. That is why, in a tropical storm, you should avoid tall isolated trees, open fields, and the water at the beach or the pool.
When you take off a fleece jumper in winter you hear crackling sounds and notice that your hair stands on end. What type of force produces these effects: gravitational,…
When you take off a fleece jumper in winter you hear crackling sounds and notice that your hair stands on end. What type of force produces these effects: gravitational, electrical or magnetic? Does it act by contact or at a distance?
You bring a balloon that you have rubbed with wool close to a thin stream of tap water, and the water bends towards the balloon, as shown in the figure. a) What type of…
You bring a balloon that you have rubbed with wool close to a thin stream of tap water, and the water bends towards the balloon, as shown in the figure.
- a) What type of force deflects the water?
- b) Why do we say that it acts at a distance?
- c) Would the stream bend if the balloon had not been rubbed? Justify your answer.
After rubbing a balloon with a dry cloth, the balloon attracts your hair even though the hair is not charged. a) Explain how the balloon can attract hair without…
After rubbing a balloon with a dry cloth, the balloon attracts your hair even though the hair is not charged.
- a) Explain how the balloon can attract hair without touching it.
- b) The trick stops working after a while: where do you think the charges on the balloon go?
- c) Predict whether the experiment will work better on a dry day or a humid day, and give reasons for your answer.
The magnetic force
The magnetic force is selective: it only acts on certain materials. If a metal thumbtack jumps toward a magnet before touching it, that is a force at a distance; a plastic one would not move.
The compass
The Earth behaves like an enormous magnet. The needle of a compass is a small magnet that can turn freely and orients itself with that terrestrial magnetism: that is why it points roughly north. It has been used for centuries to find one's way at sea and in the mountains. If you bring a strong magnet close, the needle deflects toward it and the compass is no longer reliable. To make one on the spot: magnetize a needle by rubbing it with a magnet always in the same direction, place it on a cork floating in water, and it will orient itself.
Marta is playing with two bar magnets that have their poles labelled, as shown in the figure. What happens if she brings two north poles together? What if she brings a…
Marta is playing with two bar magnets that have their poles labelled, as shown in the figure.
What happens if she brings two north poles together? What if she brings a north pole and a south pole together? Write the general rule for magnetic poles.
What is a compass and what has it been used for over the centuries? Why does its needle always point approximately towards the north?
What is a compass and what has it been used for over the centuries? Why does its needle always point approximately towards the north?
The needle of a compass points to the north, but when bringing a powerful magnet close, it deflects from its position. a) Why does the needle deflect? b) What does this…
The needle of a compass points to the north, but when bringing a powerful magnet close, it deflects from its position.
- a) Why does the needle deflect?
- b) What does this tell us about why the compass points to the north when there are no magnets nearby?
- c) Would it be reliable to navigate using a compass inside a box full of magnets?
A hiker has lost their compass, but they have a sewing needle, a small magnet and a cork stopper, and they can get a glass of water. a) Propose a method to make an…
A hiker has lost their compass, but they have a sewing needle, a small magnet and a cork stopper, and they can get a glass of water.
- a) Propose a method to make an improvised compass using these objects.
- b) Explain why the needle will end up pointing approximately north.
- c) What would happen to all the compasses in the world if the Earth stopped behaving like a magnet?
Comparing the forces
Classify these phenomena according to the force of nature that produces them (gravitational, electrical or magnetic): a) A pear falls off a tree. b) A paperclip sticks…
Classify these phenomena according to the force of nature that produces them (gravitational, electrical or magnetic):
- a) A pear falls off a tree.
- b) A paperclip sticks to the fridge magnet.
- c) When taking clothes out of the tumble dryer, some socks stick to a t-shirt.
- d) The Moon orbits the Earth without escaping.
The planets of the solar system orbit the Sun without leaving their orbits. What force holds them back? Does the Sun need to touch the planets to attract them?
The planets of the solar system orbit the Sun without leaving their orbits. What force holds them back? Does the Sun need to touch the planets to attract them?
Teo moves a paperclip on top of the table by sliding a magnet under the tabletop, without touching the paperclip at any point, as shown in the figure. a) What type of…
Teo moves a paperclip on top of the table by sliding a magnet under the tabletop, without touching the paperclip at any point, as shown in the figure.
- a) What type of force acts on the paperclip?
- b) Name another force of nature that also acts without contact.
- c) State one similarity and one difference between the magnetic force and the gravitational force.
Compare the three forces of nature studied in this unit (gravitational, electrical and magnetic) by answering these questions for each one: does it attract all objects…
Compare the three forces of nature studied in this unit (gravitational, electrical and magnetic) by answering these questions for each one: does it attract all objects or only some?, can it also repel?, does it need contact? Finish by giving an everyday example of each.
Back to the beginning: the paper clip moves because of the magnetic force, the socks stick because of the electric force of the charges from rubbing, and the mango falls because of the Earth's gravitational force.