Back to homeEconomics · Economics · Change subject
Start for free
Economics · Economics
Economic decisions · Economics and scarcity

Needs, goods and scarcity

Your school's Friday night football game has room for 2,000 fans, but 3,500 students want tickets. Not everyone can get in, so something has to decide who does.

That mismatch between what people want and what is available is where economics begins: it is the study of how limited resources are allocated among competing wants. By the end of this page you will be able to answer the ticket question, and see why every society faces the same problem.

Needs and wants

Visual comparison between need and want, highlighting that the difference depends on each person's situation and not just on the object. Need its absence prevents functioning Want improves wellbeing, is dispensable the classification depends on the person, not just on the object

Economists often sort needs into two groups. Primary needs are essential for life and health (food, housing, basic clothing, medicine). Secondary needs make life better or are tied to a lifestyle, and they can be adjusted when money is tight (streaming, a gym, vacations).

Practice★☆☆Not started
Explain in your own words what an economic need is and how it differs from a simple want. Give two examples of each related to your life as a student.

Explain in your own words what an economic need is and how it differs from a simple want. Give two examples of each related to your life as a student.

Solve
Practice★☆☆Not started
Needs change over time: ask an older person which things in your daily life did not exist when they were your age (cell phone, internet, wireless headphones). What does…

Needs change over time: ask an older person which things in your daily life did not exist when they were your age (cell phone, internet, wireless headphones). What does that show about the idea that human needs are unlimited?

Solve
Practice★★☆Not started
A family reviews its monthly expenses: rent, streaming service, food, gym, medicines, and vacations. Classify each expense as a primary or secondary need and explain…

A family reviews its monthly expenses: rent, streaming service, food, gym, medicines, and vacations. Classify each expense as a primary or secondary need and explain which ones could be cut with the least cost if their income fell.

Solve
Practice★★★Not started
A study on household expenditure in Spain shows that families in the lowest income decile allocate, on average, a higher percentage of their budget to cell phone service…

A study on household expenditure in Spain shows that families in the lowest income decile allocate, on average, a higher percentage of their budget to cell phone service and internet connection ($6.8\ \%$) than to footwear and clothing ($4.1\ \%$).

  1. a) Based on these data, refute the categorical statement that «secondary needs are merely superfluous inventions created by advertising». Justify how the concept of primary need evolves socially and whether digital connectivity can be considered a basic necessity in a developed economy.
  2. b) Analyze the opportunity cost faced by these vulnerable households when prioritizing digital spending over other basic consumption, and argue to what extent this choice reflects a sovereign decision or a necessity imposed by the economic structure of the environment.
Solve

Free goods and economic goods

Classification of goods according to their availability, distinguishing between free and economic goods, and according to their tangibility into material goods and services. Free good abundant, no cost Economic good scarce, requires a cost the classification can change over time or place

Free to you, costly to society

When something costs you nothing extra at the moment you use it, you have no reason to hold back. But the resources used are still scarce. Economists look at the marginal cost: the cost of one more unit.

Practice★☆☆Not started
Classify the following goods as free or economic goods and justify each decision: the air you breathe in the countryside, a sandwich from the cafeteria, sunlight, a…

Classify the following goods as free or economic goods and justify each decision: the air you breathe in the countryside, a sandwich from the cafeteria, sunlight, a movie ticket, bottled water, and the school's Wi-Fi.

Solve
Practice★☆☆Not started
Distinguish between physical goods and services, and classify the following: a haircut, a backpack, a dental check-up, a notebook, and the bus ride to school. Justify…

Distinguish between physical goods and services, and classify the following: a haircut, a backpack, a dental check-up, a notebook, and the bus ride to school. Justify each classification.

Solve
Practice★☆☆Not started
Water falls free from the sky, and yet tap water is paid for. Explain, using the concepts of free good and economic good, what turns it into an economic good: what work…

Water falls free from the sky, and yet tap water is paid for. Explain, using the concepts of free good and economic good, what turns it into an economic good: what work and what infrastructure lie behind the tap.

Solve
Practice★★★Not started
In a university residence hall, the dining hall is included in a fixed monthly fee (flat-rate full board). At the end of the semester, it is found that $25.0\ \%$ of the…

In a university residence hall, the dining hall is included in a fixed monthly fee (flat-rate full board). At the end of the semester, it is found that $25.0\ \%$ of the food served is thrown directly into the trash.

  1. a) Interpret this waste from the perspective of marginal cost for the resident: why does a good perceived as free at the point of consumption alter incentives and generate an inefficient allocation of scarce resources?
  2. b) Management is considering two reforms:
  • Measure 1: Reduce the fixed monthly fee and charge for each dish individually according to its actual cost.

  • Measure 2: Charge a deposit of $2.00\text{ \$}$ when picking up the tray, refundable only if it is returned with no leftover food.

Predict the incentives and possible perverse effects of each measure, and justify which one you would choose to minimize waste with the lowest management cost.

Solve

Relative scarcity

Flow diagram of the economic problem: the tension between limited resources and unlimited needs forces us to choose and give things up. Resources limited Needs unlimited Choose and give up Scarcity

Choice and opportunity cost

Because resources are limited and wants are not, every choice is a trade-off. The opportunity cost of a choice is the value of the next best alternative you give up.

To prioritize a wish list when money is short, you can rank items by need versus want, or compare how much satisfaction each dollar buys, and fund the best ones first.

The four factors of production

Anything that is produced uses scarce resources, called factors of production. Each earns an income:

Land: natural resources and space (a parking spot, soil, water). Earns rent.

Labor: the work and skills of people (a cook, a driver). Earns wages.

Capital: tools, machines and buildings used to produce (a grill, a truck). Earns interest.

Entrepreneurship: organizing the other factors and taking risks (the owner of a food truck). Earns profit.

A food truck uses a rented lot (land), cooks (labor), a grill and a truck (capital), and an owner who risks her savings (entrepreneurship).

Practice★☆☆Not started
The diagram summarizes the basic economic problem, but one of the boxes is covered with a question mark. State which concept is missing and explain with one sentence…

The diagram summarizes the basic economic problem, but one of the boxes is covered with a question mark. State which concept is missing and explain with one sentence what each step of the diagram means.

Unlimited needs Limited resources ? Choices must be made
Solve
Practice★☆☆Not started
Explain what it means for a resource to be scarce. Identify three scarce resources in your school (spaces, equipment, someone's time) and describe what decisions each…

Explain what it means for a resource to be scarce. Identify three scarce resources in your school (spaces, equipment, someone's time) and describe what decisions each one forces people to make.

Solve
Practice★☆☆Not started
Time is also a scarce resource. List everything you would like to do on a Sunday and estimate the hours each activity would take: if the total exceeds the hours in the…

Time is also a scarce resource. List everything you would like to do on a Sunday and estimate the hours each activity would take: if the total exceeds the hours in the day, explain what basic economic problem you are facing and how you solve it.

Solve
Practice★★☆Not started
Explain why we say that scarcity forces us to choose. Illustrate this with an example of your own where you have $\$20…

Explain why we say that scarcity forces us to choose. Illustrate this with an example of your own where you have $\$20$ and a whole Saturday ahead of you: what options you consider, which one you choose, and what you give up.

Solve

Allocation mechanisms in the face of scarcity

Comparison of the mechanisms for allocating scarce resources: market price, first come first served, lottery and administrative criterion. Price: whoever values it most pays First come, first served: first to ask Lottery: equal probability Administrative criterion: income, urgency

Three questions, three kinds of answers

Every society must answer: what to produce, how to produce it, and for whom. There are three classic ways to answer them. In a market system, prices and individual choices decide. In a command system, a central authority decides. In a traditional system, custom decides. The rationing mechanisms above are small versions of these answers: price is the market, an administrative criterion is command.

Examples: in a market, food trucks decide what to cook, how, and for whom by following prices and profit. In a command system, a central planner assigns factory output and rations goods. In a traditional system, a family farming community grows the same crops with the same methods its ancestors used and shares the harvest by custom.

Price, effective demand and need

Price rations by effective demand: the wants of people who are both willing and able to pay. A real need without the money to back it does not count in the market, which raises a problem of equity (fairness). A price also gives an incentive to conserve and to supply more.

Back to the start: the school answers the ticket question with some mechanism (price, lottery, first come first served, or a criterion such as seniority), but scarcity itself, 2,000 seats for 3,500 fans, stays.

Practice★★☆Not started
The school cafeteria bakes $200$ sandwiches a day and there are $500$ students who would like to buy one for $\$2…

The school cafeteria bakes $200$ sandwiches a day and there are $500$ students who would like to buy one for $\$2$.

  1. a) Is there a shortage of sandwiches at that price? Justify your answer using the data.
  2. b) Propose two different ways of distributing the available sandwiches and explain the criterion used by each.
Solve
Practice★★☆Not started
The school parking lot has $40$ spaces and $95$ applications have been submitted. a) Is there a shortage of spaces? Justify your answer using the data. b) Compare three…

The school parking lot has $40$ spaces and $95$ applications have been submitted.

  1. a) Is there a shortage of spaces? Justify your answer using the data.
  2. b) Compare three criteria for allocating the spaces (charging a price, holding a lottery, awarding them by seniority) and assess what each one gains and loses.
Solve
Practice★★☆Not started
A city council organizes a free concert in a square with room for $5,000$ people and $20,000$ sign up. a) Is the concert a free good? Justify your answer. b) What…

A city council organizes a free concert in a square with room for $5,000$ people and $20,000$ sign up.

  1. a) Is the concert a free good? Justify your answer.
  2. b) What allocation mechanisms can be used when there is not enough room? Name two and comment on their effects.
Solve

Summary

See all the exercises in this section