Evolutionary theories
The giraffe's long neck seems tailor-made for reaching the highest leaves. For centuries, explaining how it came to be that way divided scientists: did the giraffe strive to stretch itself, or did the ones born with longer necks survive?
Lamarckism: use changes the individual
A blacksmith develops very strong arms after decades of forging metal every day, but his newborn children have arms as frail as those of any other baby: can what a living thing acquires through use during its lifetime be passed on to its offspring?
Explain what biological evolution is and what it means to state that present-day species descend from other species of the past.
Explain what biological evolution is and what it means to state that present-day species descend from other species of the past.
Summarise Lamarck's two main ideas (use and disuse of organs and inheritance of acquired characteristics) and explain how he interpreted the long neck of giraffes.
Summarise Lamarck's two main ideas (use and disuse of organs and inheritance of acquired characteristics) and explain how he interpreted the long neck of giraffes.
Darwinism: natural selection
After a prolonged drought in a meadow, a few wild plants manage to flower while the rest dry up, simply because their roots were a few centimetres deeper from the moment they germinated: how can an entire population change generation after generation without any individual changing by itself?
Summarise the key ideas of Darwinism: variation among individuals, the struggle for existence and natural selection of the best adapted.
Summarise the key ideas of Darwinism: variation among individuals, the struggle for existence and natural selection of the best adapted.
Explain what fixism or creationism claimed about the origin and the permanence of species, and why fossils of animals that no longer exist were a problem for that idea.
Explain what fixism or creationism claimed about the origin and the permanence of species, and why fossils of animals that no longer exist were a problem for that idea.
Look at the diagram, which shows two different explanations (A and B) of how giraffes came to have long necks. State which corresponds to Lamarck and which to Darwin,…
Look at the diagram, which shows two different explanations (A and B) of how giraffes came to have long necks. State which corresponds to Lamarck and which to Darwin, and point out the fundamental difference between the two regarding what is inherited.
Lamarckism and Darwinism: the key difference
What does Neo-Darwinism or the synthetic theory add to Darwin's ideas? Explain how genetics (mutations and inheritance) completed the theory of natural selection.
What does Neo-Darwinism or the synthetic theory add to Darwin's ideas? Explain how genetics (mutations and inheritance) completed the theory of natural selection.
Name and briefly describe three lines of evidence for evolution: fossils, comparative anatomy (homologous bones) and biogeography.
Name and briefly describe three lines of evidence for evolution: fossils, comparative anatomy (homologous bones) and biogeography.
On a small island, a prolonged drought wipes out soft-seeded plants, and only those with large, hard seeds survive. A team of biologists measures beak depth in a finch…
On a small island, a prolonged drought wipes out soft-seeded plants, and only those with large, hard seeds survive. A team of biologists measures beak depth in a finch population before the drought (mean of 8,8 mm) and one year later among the survivors (mean of 9,8 mm). A) Justify using the synthetic theory what has happened in the population at the phenotypic and genotypic levels. B) A student comments: "The finches had to strive to crack the hard seeds, which caused their beaks to grow 1 mm during their lifetime, and that is why their offspring were born with larger beaks." Refute their statement by pointing out why it falls into Lamarckism and how natural selection actually operates.
The modern synthesis: Darwin plus genetics
Darwin brilliantly showed that the environment selects the most effective variants, but his contemporaries raised a devastating objection: if the traits of the parents blend and become diluted with each cross, where exactly do biological novelties come from and how do they manage to be preserved intact?
Lamarck's theory seemed reasonable in its time. Explain what fact about heredity Lamarck did not know that today allows us to reject the inheritance of acquired…
Lamarck's theory seemed reasonable in its time. Explain what fact about heredity Lamarck did not know that today allows us to reject the inheritance of acquired characteristics, and what a Lamarckist and a Darwinist would each say about why gazelles run fast.
In an English industrial region, the proportion of dark (carbonaria*) and light (typica*) peppered moths (Biston betularia*) was measured. After anti-coal pollution laws…
In an English industrial region, the proportion of dark (carbonaria) and light (typica) peppered moths (Biston betularia) was measured. After anti-coal pollution laws were passed in 1960, records showed: in 1960, 90% dark moths; in 1980, 50%; and in 2000, only 10%. A) Interpret these data by identifying the natural selection factor and explaining why the allele frequencies changed. B) Predict with reasoned arguments what would happen to the proportion of both varieties if a new nocturnal predator were introduced that locates its prey exclusively by smell and not by sight.
Analyze the following two situations: 1) If the tails of mice are surgically amputated for several successive generations, all offspring in subsequent litters continue…
Analyze the following two situations: 1) If the tails of mice are surgically amputated for several successive generations, all offspring in subsequent litters continue to be born with intact tails. 2) If the testes of male mice are irradiated with X-rays, many of their offspring are born with tail malformations. A) Justify these results based on the difference between somatic cells and germline cells. B) If a bodybuilder were to use gene therapy to modify the DNA of their arm muscle fibers to induce hypertrophy, would their descendants inherit that muscle mass? Justify your answer.
Selection, genetic drift and gene flow
Natural selection changes the frequencies of heritable variants through differences in reproductive success. Genetic drift changes them by chance, especially in small populations. Gene flow introduces or removes alleles when there is migration and reproduction. Mutation produces new alleles; recombination forms new combinations.
Back to the beginning: the giraffes that survived were those born with longer necks thanks to pre-existing genetic variation; the environment selected the best-fed ones, and individual effort does not alter the DNA that can be passed on to the offspring.