Scientific communication
Aitana heats some water and writes down the temperature every minute. If she only writes the bare numbers, nobody else will be able to understand them. Science does not end with the experiment: you have to communicate what has been done and what has been found, so that anyone can repeat it.
The parts of a report
You read an article claiming that a plant grows twice as much with classical music, but it does not say which instruments were used or how growth was measured. What structure should a report have so that anyone can repeat the experiment and check it?
A scientific report has these sections, but they are out of order: conclusions, aim and hypothesis, results, equipment and procedure. Put them in order and write one…
A scientific report has these sections, but they are out of order: conclusions, aim and hypothesis, results, equipment and procedure. Put them in order and write one sentence about what is included in each section.
State which section of the report each sentence belongs to: a) "We used two beakers, a measuring cylinder, a thermometer and a stopwatch." b) "The salt dissolved faster…
State which section of the report each sentence belongs to:
- a) "We used two beakers, a measuring cylinder, a thermometer and a stopwatch."
- b) "The salt dissolved faster in hot water."
- c) "We wanted to test whether water temperature affects the dissolving of salt."
- d) "The results support our initial hypothesis."
Data tables
You find a piece of paper with the pairs of numbers "0 - 15", "5 - 30" and "10 - 45", but nobody knows whether they are minutes and degrees or seconds and metres. How do we organise these data so that they can be understood on their own?
In a report table, the first column is titled simply "time" and the second simply "temperature". Rewrite both headings as they should appear in a scientific report, with…
In a report table, the first column is titled simply "time" and the second simply "temperature". Rewrite both headings as they should appear in a scientific report, with the quantity and unit in brackets.
In an experiment on dissolving sugar, the following unordered data was obtained: at $40\ ^\circ\text{C}$ it takes $20\ \text{s}$; at $20\ ^\circ\text{C}$ it takes…
In an experiment on dissolving sugar, the following unordered data was obtained: at $40\ ^\circ\text{C}$ it takes $20\ \text{s}$; at $20\ ^\circ\text{C}$ it takes $60\ \text{s}$; at $60\ ^\circ\text{C}$ it takes $10\ \text{s}$. Organise them in a two-column table and write the heading for each column showing its quantity and unit.
A classmate hands in this table from a water heating experiment: the first column reads "time ($\text{min}$)" with values $0$, $5$ and $10$, and the second reads simply…
A classmate hands in this table from a water heating experiment: the first column reads "time ($\text{min}$)" with values $0$, $5$ and $10$, and the second reads simply "temperature" with values $20$, $35$ and $50$.
- a) What is missing from the second column heading?
- b) Why is this mistake important?
- c) Rewrite the column heading correctly.
Graphs
You see a graph with a line that rises quickly, but the axes have no labels or units, only numbers. What minimum information does that image need for us to know what is really happening?
A graph shows the height of a sunflower during the first three weeks of its growth. Look at the graph: a) How tall was the sunflower in week $2$? b) How much did it grow…
A graph shows the height of a sunflower during the first three weeks of its growth. Look at the graph:
- a) How tall was the sunflower in week $2$?
- b) How much did it grow between week $1$ and week $3$?
List the three things every graph must have to be understandable: a title, the label of the horizontal axis (with its quantity and its unit) and the label of the…
List the three things every graph must have to be understandable: a title, the label of the horizontal axis (with its quantity and its unit) and the label of the vertical axis (with its quantity and its unit). Then, explain why drawing the line is not enough.
A graph shows how a cup of tea cools down: when poured it is at $70\ ^\circ\text{C}$; after $10$ minutes, at $50\ ^\circ\text{C}$; and after $20$ minutes, at…
A graph shows how a cup of tea cools down: when poured it is at $70\ ^\circ\text{C}$; after $10$ minutes, at $50\ ^\circ\text{C}$; and after $20$ minutes, at $40\ ^\circ\text{C}$. Observe the graph:
- a) How much did the temperature drop between minute $10$ and minute $20$?
- b) Calculate how much it dropped in the first $10$ minutes and state in which of the two intervals it dropped more.
Maximum, minimum and comparing data
These data are the temperatures, in °C, of five classrooms. Compare the maximum and minimum; notice that without the unit (°C) the numbers alone would not let you draw any physical conclusion.
Here are the times for the $100\ \text{m}$ sprint of four friends: $14$, $16$, $15$ and $13$ seconds. a) State the maximum and minimum values. b) Who ran faster, the…
Here are the times for the $100\ \text{m}$ sprint of four friends: $14$, $16$, $15$ and $13$ seconds.
- a) State the maximum and minimum values.
- b) Who ran faster, the person with the maximum time or the minimum time? Explain why.
You want to see at a glance whether the swimming pool water heats up faster and faster throughout the day. What would you present: a table or a graph? Justify your…
You want to see at a glance whether the swimming pool water heats up faster and faster throughout the day. What would you present: a table or a graph? Justify your choice.
A graph in a report has no title, the horizontal axis only says "time" without a unit, and the vertical axis has no label at all. a) Point out all the mistakes. b)…
A graph in a report has no title, the horizontal axis only says "time" without a unit, and the vertical axis has no label at all.
- a) Point out all the mistakes.
- b) Rewrite how that graph should be presented (full title and labels) if it shows how water is heated over $10$ minutes.
- c) Explain the problem with interpreting a graph without units.
Back to the start: For anyone to understand Aitana's experiment, she must arrange her measurements in a table with complete headings ("time (min)" and "temperature (°C)") and draw the corresponding graph.