Modelling and the economic method
Economics cannot observe the whole U.S. economy under a microscope or repeat the Great Recession in a laboratory. To understand such complex phenomena, economists build simplified representations of reality that keep what is essential and discard the rest: models. Every graph you will use in AP Macro, from the PPC to AD–AS, is one of them.
Economic models
Explain what an economic model is and why simplifying reality is not a flaw but a necessity. Compare it to a subway map: how is it similar to and how does it differ from…
Explain what an economic model is and why simplifying reality is not a flaw but a necessity. Compare it to a subway map: how is it similar to and how does it differ from the real city?
A café wants a simple model to predict how many coffees it will sell depending on the price it sets. State which two variables the model would include, which things it…
A café wants a simple model to predict how many coffees it will sell depending on the price it sets. State which two variables the model would include, which things it would leave out (weather, exams, road construction on the street) and why leaving them out does not make the model useless.
A model of the sandwich market assumes that all buyers know the prices of all cafeterias and that all sandwiches are identical. a) Why are these assumptions not met in…
A model of the sandwich market assumes that all buyers know the prices of all cafeterias and that all sandwiches are identical.
- a) Why are these assumptions not met in reality?
- b) Why can the model still be useful despite this?
Variables, assumptions and the *ceteris paribus* clause
What does the Latin phrase "ceteris paribus" mean and why do economists use it? Give an example applied to the relationship between movie ticket prices and the number of…
What does the Latin phrase "ceteris paribus" mean and why do economists use it? Give an example applied to the relationship between movie ticket prices and the number of viewers.
Explain what an economic variable is and give three examples (price, quantity sold, household income). Then, in the statement "if it gets hotter, more ice cream is…
Explain what an economic variable is and give three examples (price, quantity sold, household income). Then, in the statement "if it gets hotter, more ice cream is sold", indicate which variable is to be explained and which is used to explain it.
What is an assumption within a model? Point out two hidden assumptions in this statement: "if the bus fare falls, more students will use it" (think about trip time,…
What is an assumption within a model? Point out two hidden assumptions in this statement: "if the bus fare falls, more students will use it" (think about trip time, distances, or the price of the alternatives).
A movie theater raises its ticket price by $15\ \%$ and yet is fuller than ever because it has released the movie of the year. Using the phrase "ceteris paribus",…
A movie theater raises its ticket price by $15\ \%$ and yet is fuller than ever because it has released the movie of the year. Using the phrase "ceteris paribus", explain why this case does not refute the model that a higher price means fewer sales. Which variable that the model assumed to be fixed has moved?
The scientific method in economics
Before you start: the weather service can say "70% chance of rain" and be right, but a forecast of a recession can change what people do. Keep that in mind at the end of this section.
The figure shows the steps of the scientific method applied to economics, with one step covered by a question mark. State which step is missing and explain what is done…
The figure shows the steps of the scientific method applied to economics, with one step covered by a question mark. State which step is missing and explain what is done in each of the others.
What is a prediction in economics and how do you check whether it was accurate? Give an example of a prediction about the market in your town (rental prices, store…
What is a prediction in economics and how do you check whether it was accurate? Give an example of a prediction about the market in your town (rental prices, store openings) and explain what data you would look at a year later.
A stationery store records the price of its notebooks and the units sold for four weeks in a row: at $\$3$ it sells $90$; at $\$4$, $75$; at $\$5$, $62$; at $\$6$, $50$.…
A stationery store records the price of its notebooks and the units sold for four weeks in a row: at $\$3$ it sells $90$; at $\$4$, $75$; at $\$5$, $62$; at $\$6$, $50$.
- a) What pattern do the data suggest?
- b) Formulate a model hypothesis and a testable prediction for a price of $\$7$, stating what assumption you are making.
Correlation, causation and the fallacy of composition
This section is brief: you need it to read AP Macro graphs correctly. When a curve shifts, ask whether the shift is caused by the variable on the axis or by another factor held constant under ceteris paribus.
Another trap is ignoring the counterfactual: what would have happened without the change. If youth unemployment stays flat after a minimum wage increase, it might have fallen without it, so you need a comparison group or a trend to judge.
In summer, ice cream sales rise and so do drownings at beaches, but nobody says that ice cream causes drownings. Use this example to explain the difference between…
In summer, ice cream sales rise and so do drownings at beaches, but nobody says that ice cream causes drownings. Use this example to explain the difference between correlation and causation, and why confusing them leads to bad decisions.
During an economic recession, a pundit states: "Any sensible family knows that if their income falls, they must tighten their belt and cut their spending as much as…
During an economic recession, a pundit states: "Any sensible family knows that if their income falls, they must tighten their belt and cut their spending as much as possible to get through the rough patch. Therefore, the best policy for the country to overcome the crisis is for all families, businesses, and government agencies to simultaneously reduce their spending by $15\,\%$."
- a) Relying on the circular flow of income model, refute the pundit's argument: predict what will happen to firms' revenues and employment if all agents attempt to cut their spending at the same time.
- b) Explain the methodological error the pundit makes by directly extrapolating an individual behavioral pattern (microeconomics) to the whole country (macroeconomics), and propose another economic situation (other than saving or spending) where this same fallacy of composition occurs.