Newton's third law: action and reaction
Picture a Friday night football game: a running back digs his cleats into the turf and pushes backward, yet he surges forward. If he pushes backward, why doesn't he move backward? The answer is Newton's third law.
The third law: to every action, a reaction
If you are standing still on roller skates and you gently push a classmate, you find that you roll backward even though nobody has pushed you directly. Why does exerting a force on another object automatically produce a force on your own body in the opposite direction?
Complete the statement of Newton's third law: "If an object A exerts a force on an object B, then B exerts on A another force with the same $\dots$, the same $\dots$,…
Complete the statement of Newton's third law: "If an object A exerts a force on an object B, then B exerts on A another force with the same $\dots$, the same $\dots$, and $\dots$ direction". Then give an everyday example.
When walking, your foot pushes the ground backward, yet you move forward. Identify the action and reaction forces: explain who exerts each one and which body it acts…
When walking, your foot pushes the ground backward, yet you move forward. Identify the action and reaction forces: explain who exerts each one and which body it acts upon.
To jump upward, you bend your legs and push the ground downward. Explain using Newton's third law why you are propelled upward. What is actually pushing you?
To jump upward, you bend your legs and push the ground downward. Explain using Newton's third law why you are propelled upward. What is actually pushing you?
If you punch a wall, you hurt your hand, even though the wall did not move. Explain, using Newton's third law, where the force that causes the pain comes from.
If you punch a wall, you hurt your hand, even though the wall did not move. Explain, using Newton's third law, where the force that causes the pain comes from.
Action-reaction pairs in sport and transport
Third-law pairs are everywhere in sports and rides: a baseball bat and the ball, a swimmer and the water, a skater and her partner. Take a roller coaster: at the bottom of a dip, the seat pushes up on you (action on you) while you push down on the seat (reaction on the seat). The car's wheels also push down on the track while the track pushes back up on the wheels. That is why you feel pressed into your seat. Each force in a pair acts on a different body.
A swimmer moves forward because her arms push the water backward. Explain, using Newton's third law, why pushing the water backward propels her forward.
A swimmer moves forward because her arms push the water backward. Explain, using Newton's third law, why pushing the water backward propels her forward.
For a rowboat to move forward, the rower pushes the water backward with the blades of the oars. Explain what force the water exerts on the oars and why the boat moves…
For a rowboat to move forward, the rower pushes the water backward with the blades of the oars. Explain what force the water exerts on the oars and why the boat moves forward.
Two ice skaters, stationary and facing each other, push off each other with their hands, as shown in the figure. Both slide away in opposite directions. a) Identify the…
Two ice skaters, stationary and facing each other, push off each other with their hands, as shown in the figure. Both slide away in opposite directions.
- a) Identify the action and the reaction.
- b) If one has a mass of $40\ \text{kg}$ and the other $80\ \text{kg}$, which one moves faster? Justify your answer by combining Newton's third and second laws.
A boy jumps from the bow of a small boat toward the dock, as shown in the diagram. As he jumps, the boat moves backward and the boy almost falls into the water. a)…
A boy jumps from the bow of a small boat toward the dock, as shown in the diagram. As he jumps, the boat moves backward and the boy almost falls into the water.
- a) Explain why the boat moves.
- b) Predict what would happen if he jumped from a large ferry instead of a small boat. Justify your answer by considering their masses.
When you jump, you push the Earth downward with a force of $600\ \text{N}$ and the Earth pushes you upward with another $600\ \text{N}$, as shown in the diagram. a)…
When you jump, you push the Earth downward with a force of $600\ \text{N}$ and the Earth pushes you upward with another $600\ \text{N}$, as shown in the diagram.
- a) Calculate your initial acceleration if your mass is $60\ \text{kg}$ (do a simplified calculation, without subtracting your weight).
- b) The mass of the Earth is about $6\times10^{24}\ \text{kg}$: calculate the acceleration you produce on the Earth.
- c) Explain why no one notices the Earth moving when we jump.
Reaction propulsion: rockets and balloons
When NASA launches a rocket from Kennedy Space Center, the engines shove hot gas down and the rocket shoots up. The same idea works on a much bigger scale in Earth's crust: tectonic plates push on each other along a fault with equal and opposite forces.
You inflate a balloon and release it without tying it: it shoots off while deflating. What force propels it? Identify the action and reaction in this case, indicating…
You inflate a balloon and release it without tying it: it shoots off while deflating. What force propels it? Identify the action and reaction in this case, indicating which body each force acts upon.
A rocket ascends because it expels gases downward at high speed, as shown in the figure. Identify the action-reaction pair and explain why the rocket accelerates upward.
A rocket ascends because it expels gases downward at high speed, as shown in the figure.
Identify the action-reaction pair and explain why the rocket accelerates upward.
When fired, a cannon pushes the cannonball forward while the cannon itself recoils backward, as shown in the figure. a) Explain the recoil using Newton's third law. b)…
When fired, a cannon pushes the cannonball forward while the cannon itself recoils backward, as shown in the figure.
- a) Explain the recoil using Newton's third law.
- b) If the force acting on the cannonball and on the cannon is the same, why does the cannon recoil much more slowly than the cannonball shoots out? Consider their masses.
A typical mistake: do the forces of the pair cancel out?
Walking also needs friction. On smooth ice your foot slips backward because the ice cannot push forward on you with much force; on a dry sidewalk, rough soles grip, so the ground can push you forward.
A student claims: "If every action has an equal and opposite reaction, the two forces cancel each other out and nothing could ever move." Explain where their mistake…
A student claims: "If every action has an equal and opposite reaction, the two forces cancel each other out and nothing could ever move." Explain where their mistake lies, reasoning about which body each force acts upon. Think about the case of a person walking.
Walking on smooth ice is almost impossible: your feet slip backward when trying to move forward. Relate this problem to the reaction force from the ground used for…
Walking on smooth ice is almost impossible: your feet slip backward when trying to move forward. Relate this problem to the reaction force from the ground used for walking, and explain why we can walk normally with rough-soled shoes on a dry sidewalk.
In a fable, a horse refuses to pull a cart, arguing: 'If I pull the cart forward with a force, Newton's third law says the cart pulls back on me with an equal force; so…
In a fable, a horse refuses to pull a cart, arguing: 'If I pull the cart forward with a force, Newton's third law says the cart pulls back on me with an equal force; so we can never move.' Gently explain to the horse where its reasoning is wrong, indicating which body each force acts upon and what other forces (those of the ground on its hooves) make the movement possible.
A boy is inside a train car and pushes the back wall with all his strength: the car does not move. He steps outside onto the platform, pushes the same wall from there,…
A boy is inside a train car and pushes the back wall with all his strength: the car does not move. He steps outside onto the platform, pushes the same wall from there, and the car begins to roll slowly.
- a) Explain using Newton's third law why he cannot move it from inside: think about the forces exerted between the boy and the car (including at his feet).
- b) Why can he move it from the outside? Which body receives the reaction force now?
- c) Relate this to the impossibility of "lifting oneself up by pulling one's own hair."
On a drifting raft, with no current or wind, a castaway sets up a battery-powered fan blowing against the sail of the boat to try to move forward, as shown in the…
On a drifting raft, with no current or wind, a castaway sets up a battery-powered fan blowing against the sail of the boat to try to move forward, as shown in the diagram.
- a) Will the raft move forward? Analyze the forces between the fan, the air, and the sail using Newton's third law.
- b) What if he removed the sail and pointed the fan backward, blowing the air out of the boat? Compare the two cases.
Back to the beginning: When you take a step, your foot exerts a force backwards on the ground (action); instantly and inevitably, the ground exerts an identical force on your foot forwards (reaction): that external force that you receive from the ground is what drives you forwards.
Summary
A squid propels itself by squirting a jet of water through a siphon. Explain how it uses Newton's third law to escape predators and name another animal, or a means of…
A squid propels itself by squirting a jet of water through a siphon. Explain how it uses Newton's third law to escape predators and name another animal, or a means of transportation, that moves using the same principle.
When hitting a ball with a racket, a tennis player feels a sharp impact on their arm. a) Identify the action and reaction forces in the collision between the racket and…
When hitting a ball with a racket, a tennis player feels a sharp impact on their arm.
- a) Identify the action and reaction forces in the collision between the racket and the ball.
- b) Explain why the much lighter ball shoots off, while the arm barely slows down.
A $100\ \text{g}$ frog jumps horizontally from a $200\ \text{g}$ lily pad floating still in the water, as shown in the diagram. a) If the frog pushes the leaf with a…
A $100\ \text{g}$ frog jumps horizontally from a $200\ \text{g}$ lily pad floating still in the water, as shown in the diagram.
- a) If the frog pushes the leaf with a force of $2\ \text{N}$, with what force does the leaf push the frog? Justify your answer using Newton's third law.
- b) Convert the masses to $\text{kg}$ and calculate the initial acceleration of the frog and that of the leaf.
- c) Explain why the leaf moves backwards less than the distance the frog jumps.
Identify, in each scene, the action force, the reaction force, and the body upon which each force acts: a) A basketball player bounces the ball against the ground. b) A…
Identify, in each scene, the action force, the reaction force, and the body upon which each force acts:
- a) A basketball player bounces the ball against the ground.
- b) A swimmer pushes off against the pool wall to turn around.
- c) A standing fan on casters tends to move backward when turned on.
Alex ($50\ \text{kg}$) and Martina ($40\ \text{kg}$), both on scooters and at rest, push off against each other. During the push, each exerts an average force of…
Alex ($50\ \text{kg}$) and Martina ($40\ \text{kg}$), both on scooters and at rest, push off against each other. During the push, each exerts an average force of $100\ \text{N}$ on the other for $0.5\ \text{s}$.
- a) With what force does Martina push Alex? And Alex push Martina?
- b) Calculate the acceleration of each while the push lasts.
- c) Calculate the velocity of each upon separating and comment on why the lighter one moves away faster.
At the science fair you want to launch a bottle rocket: a plastic bottle with water and pressurized air that ejects the water downward. a) Explain using Newton's third…
At the science fair you want to launch a bottle rocket: a plastic bottle with water and pressurized air that ejects the water downward.
- a) Explain using Newton's third law what propels the bottle upward.
- b) Predict the advantage of ejecting the water at a higher speed and justify your answer using Newton's laws.
- c) When the water runs out, the rocket continues to climb for a distance and then falls: explain these two stages using Newton's first law and the weight of the rocket.