Renewable and nonrenewable energy sources
The Sun, the wind, and coal are "energy sources": they are where we get the energy we use every day. But they don't all behave the same way: some renew themselves, and others, once used up, won't come back in our lifetime or our grandchildren's. What is the difference, and why does it matter so much for Mexico's future?
Renewable and nonrenewable
Every morning you turn on the light, heat your food on the stove, and head to school by bus or on the Metro. All of that uses energy that has to be taken from nature. Where exactly does it come from, and why do some sources never run out while others do?
Classify these energy sources as renewable or non-renewable: a) Solar energy. b) Coal. c) Wind energy. d) Natural gas.
Classify these energy sources as renewable or non-renewable:
- a) Solar energy.
- b) Coal.
- c) Wind energy.
- d) Natural gas.
Why do we say that solar energy is renewable? Explain in your own words, thinking about whether the Sun gets "used up" when we use it.
Why do we say that solar energy is renewable? Explain in your own words, thinking about whether the Sun gets "used up" when we use it.
Complete the sentence with the missing words: "Non-renewable sources are those that get $\dots$ when used, because nature takes $\dots$ of years to form them again. Two…
Complete the sentence with the missing words: "Non-renewable sources are those that get $\dots$ when used, because nature takes $\dots$ of years to form them again. Two examples are $\dots$ and $\dots$."
State whether each statement is true or false and correct the false ones: a) "Oil is a renewable source." b) "Firewood and pruning waste are biomass, a renewable…
State whether each statement is true or false and correct the false ones:
- a) "Oil is a renewable source."
- b) "Firewood and pruning waste are biomass, a renewable source."
- c) "If we install many wind turbines, the wind will run out."
Renewable energy
Mexico has examples of all of them: the wind farms of the Isthmus of Tehuantepec, in Oaxaca, where the wind is very steady; the Cerro Prieto geothermal plant, in Baja California; hydroelectric plants such as the Chicoasén dam, in Chiapas; and thousands of solar water heaters on rooftops across the country.
Which energy source does each of these facilities use? a) Giant wind turbines at the top of a hill. b) Dark panels on the roof of a house. c) A dam releasing water…
Which energy source does each of these facilities use?
- a) Giant wind turbines at the top of a hill.
- b) Dark panels on the roof of a house.
- c) A dam releasing water through its sluice gates.
- d) A power station burning gas to heat steam.
In some towns there are hot thermal waters that spring from the ground, heated by the Earth's interior. a) What is the name of the energy source that uses this heat? b)…
In some towns there are hot thermal waters that spring from the ground, heated by the Earth's interior.
- a) What is the name of the energy source that uses this heat?
- b) Is it renewable or non-renewable? Justify your answer.
The school has installed solar panels on the roof of the gym. a) Give two advantages of producing its own electricity in this way. b) Give one disadvantage of solar…
The school has installed solar panels on the roof of the gym.
- a) Give two advantages of producing its own electricity in this way.
- b) Give one disadvantage of solar energy and explain how it can be solved or mitigated.
A hydroelectric dam produces electricity by releasing dammed water, as shown in the diagram in the figure. a) Write down one advantage of this energy source. b) Write…
A hydroelectric dam produces electricity by releasing dammed water, as shown in the diagram in the figure.
- a) Write down one advantage of this energy source.
- b) Write down one disadvantage for the river environment and the valley.
- c) Is it renewable? Justify your answer.
Geothermal and biomass
Geothermal energy uses heat from underground, mainly in volcanic areas, so it can't be set up just anywhere. Biomass and biogas make use of waste (such as manure from a farm): they provide energy and also reduce waste, but a single type of waste isn't enough to supply a large city.
At Leo's house, they cook with a butane gas cylinder and in winter they heat the house with a fireplace. a) Which energy source does the cooker use and which does the…
At Leo's house, they cook with a butane gas cylinder and in winter they heat the house with a fireplace.
- a) Which energy source does the cooker use and which does the fireplace use?
- b) Which of the two is renewable? Why?
An entire neighbourhood is heated using geothermal heat from the subsoil. a) Why is it considered a renewable source? b) What advantage does it have over heating by…
An entire neighbourhood is heated using geothermal heat from the subsoil.
- a) Why is it considered a renewable source?
- b) What advantage does it have over heating by burning gas?
- c) Could such an installation be placed anywhere? Reason your answer.
A biomass boiler burns $4\ \text{kg}$ of pellets a day, and each kilogram provides $5\ \text{kWh}$ of heat. a) How many $\text{kWh}$ of heat does the boiler supply each…
A biomass boiler burns $4\ \text{kg}$ of pellets a day, and each kilogram provides $5\ \text{kWh}$ of heat.
- a) How many $\text{kWh}$ of heat does the boiler supply each day?
- b) How many $\text{kWh}$ does it supply in a month of $30$ days?
On a dairy farm, slurry is used to produce biogas, which is then used for cooking. a) Why is biogas considered a renewable source? b) Besides providing energy, what…
On a dairy farm, slurry is used to produce biogas, which is then used for cooking.
- a) Why is biogas considered a renewable source?
- b) Besides providing energy, what other advantage does using slurry have?
- c) Could this source supply a large city on its own? Reason your answer.
Nonrenewable energy
In a nuclear power station, uranium is used as a "fuel". a) Is nuclear energy renewable or non-renewable? Think about whether uranium gets depleted. b) Name the most…
In a nuclear power station, uranium is used as a "fuel".
- a) Is nuclear energy renewable or non-renewable? Think about whether uranium gets depleted.
- b) Name the most well-known problem with this energy source, related to what is left behind after using it.
Coal and natural gas are fossil fuels. a) What common problem do they cause for the planet's climate? Name the gas they emit when burned. b) If this problem is so…
Coal and natural gas are fossil fuels.
- a) What common problem do they cause for the planet's climate? Name the gas they emit when burned.
- b) If this problem is so serious, why do you think many countries continue to use them? Give at least one reason.
The label of an electric car says "zero emissions". a) Explain why this only comes close to being true if the electricity used to charge it comes from renewable sources.…
The label of an electric car says "zero emissions".
- a) Explain why this only comes close to being true if the electricity used to charge it comes from renewable sources.
- b) If the electricity is produced in a power station that burns coal, where are the gases emitted then? Has the problem disappeared or has it merely shifted location?
There are strongly opposing opinions regarding nuclear energy. a) Write down two arguments of those in favour: think about how much energy it provides, whether it emits…
There are strongly opposing opinions regarding nuclear energy.
- a) Write down two arguments of those in favour: think about how much energy it provides, whether it emits carbon dioxide during operation, and whether it depends on the weather.
- b) Write down two arguments of those against: think about waste and accidents.
- c) Give your reasoned opinion: should a country invest in nuclear energy while installing more renewables?
Choosing sources: advantages and limits
No source is perfect. Choosing means comparing advantages and drawbacks and making an argument.
| Source | Advantage | Drawback |
|---|---|---|
| Solar | Emits no gases; can be installed on any rooftop | Depends on day and night |
| Wind | Emits no gases; very good in the Isthmus | Depends on the wind; changes the landscape |
| Hydroelectric | Produces on demand | Floods valleys and changes the river |
| Gas, coal, oil | Produce at any hour | Emit $\text{CO}_2$ and run out |
| Nuclear | Lots of energy, no $\text{CO}_2$ | Radioactive waste |
To supply electricity at night too, sources are combined (solar by day, wind, hydroelectric) and energy is stored in batteries or in pumped-storage dams, which pump water uphill when there is extra energy and release it when it is needed.
A municipality must choose between installing a wind farm in the mountains or a small gas power plant next to the industrial park. a) Write down two arguments in favor…
A municipality must choose between installing a wind farm in the mountains or a small gas power plant next to the industrial park.
- a) Write down two arguments in favor of the wind farm.
- b) Write down two arguments in favor of the gas power plant.
- c) Choose one of the two options and defend it with your own arguments, addressing one of its disadvantages.
A town consumes $1000\ \text{kWh}$ of electricity per day and $40\ \%$ comes from renewable sources. The graph summarizes the town's energy consumption and its renewable…
A town consumes $1000\ \text{kWh}$ of electricity per day and $40\ \%$ comes from renewable sources. The graph summarizes the town's energy consumption and its renewable share.
- a) How many renewable $\text{kWh}$ does it consume per day?
- b) The following year, the number of solar panels doubles and the renewable kilowatt-hours rise to $800$. If consumption remains at $1000\ \text{kWh}$, what percentage of renewable energy does the town reach?
- c) Imagine that, with so much clean energy, people waste electricity and daily consumption increases to $1600\ \text{kWh}$ per day. What percentage is renewable then? What conclusion do you draw about installing renewables and saving energy?
Someone claims: "It is very sunny in Mexico, so all electricity should be solar by now." a) Give two reasons why this is not as easy as it seems. b) Propose a…
Someone claims: "It is very sunny in Mexico, so all electricity should be solar by now."
- a) Give two reasons why this is not as easy as it seems.
- b) Propose a combination of renewable sources that can also provide electricity at night, and justify your answer.
- c) Explain what role batteries or pumped-storage hydroelectric dams can play in that system.
Energy saving and responsible consumption
Other ways to save: use public transportation (a full bus uses much less energy per person than dozens of cars with a single passenger), ride a bike or walk, and keep your cell phone longer, because making it also uses a lot of energy.
To do your homework, you can use a desktop computer using $200\ \text{W}$ or a laptop using $50\ \text{W}$, taking $2\ \text{h}$ with either of them. a) How much energy…
To do your homework, you can use a desktop computer using $200\ \text{W}$ or a laptop using $50\ \text{W}$, taking $2\ \text{h}$ with either of them.
- a) How much energy does each one consume, in $\text{Wh}$?
- b) How many $\text{Wh}$ do you save each evening by using the laptop?
At Carla's house, the TV and games console are always left on standby, with the little light on. Together they consume $0.5\ \text{kWh}$ per day without anyone using…
At Carla's house, the TV and games console are always left on standby, with the little light on. Together they consume $0.5\ \text{kWh}$ per day without anyone using them.
- a) How many $\text{kWh}$ do they waste in a year of $365$ days?
- b) How much money is thrown away per year, at $4\ \text{\$/kWh}$?
- c) Propose two responsible consumption habits to reduce this waste.
A classmate claims: "Since the Sun and the wind are free and will not run out, saving energy will no longer be necessary once everything is renewable." a) Explain why…
A classmate claims: "Since the Sun and the wind are free and will not run out, saving energy will no longer be necessary once everything is renewable."
- a) Explain why renewable energy is not truly "free": think about the infrastructure, materials, and land required.
- b) Give one reason why saving energy will still be necessary even if all energy is renewable.
- c) Rewrite your classmate's statement so that it is correct.
Manufacturing a cell phone consumes a lot of energy: mining, manufacturing, and transportation use as much energy as years of using the device. a) Explain why changing…
Manufacturing a cell phone consumes a lot of energy: mining, manufacturing, and transportation use as much energy as years of using the device.
- a) Explain why changing cell phones every year uses a lot of energy, even if the new phone spends most of the day turned off.
- b) Propose two responsible consumption decisions that reduce this energy expenditure.
- c) Link this saving to the use of non-renewable sources.
A city bus with $40$ passengers consumes the same energy on a journey as $10$ cars travelling the same route with only one person in each, as shown in the figure. a) How…
A city bus with $40$ passengers consumes the same energy on a journey as $10$ cars travelling the same route with only one person in each, as shown in the figure.
- a) How many times less energy per person does the bus consume compared to the car?
- b) Explain why using public transport helps to use fewer non-renewable sources.
- c) Propose two other ways to reduce the energy spent on transport.
Back to the beginning: renewables regenerate and nonrenewables run out; that is why it makes sense to combine sources and, above all, to use less.