Materials Selection
In the neighborhood, they want to build a bench for the community garden and a new frying pan for the food co-op. Why isn't the pan's handle made of the same metal as the pan, and why isn't the bench in the plaza made of just anything? Choosing the right material is half of the design: every material has properties that make it ideal for one piece and unsuitable for another.
The Properties of Materials
Each property justifies a technical decision: why the handle is made of one material and the pan of another.
Mechanical properties (hardness, elasticity) tell how the material responds to forces. Thermal and electrical properties (conductivity) tell how it behaves with heat and current.
Common samples in the shop: wood (visible grain, light, insulating), copper (reddish, a very good conductor), acrylic (rigid, transparent), steel (dark gray, heavy, magnetic), and clay or ceramic (hard, insulating, brittle). Careful: not all metals are magnetic; copper and aluminum are not.
Four samples of common workshop materials are presented, numbered from 1 to 4: 1. A light-toned strip of wood with visible natural grain. 2. A shiny reddish metal sheet.…
Four samples of common workshop materials are presented, numbered from 1 to 4:
-
A light-toned strip of wood with visible natural grain.
-
A shiny reddish metal sheet.
-
A rigid, colorless, transparent sheet.
-
A dark gray, heavy, magnetic metal bar.
Identify them and suggest an object you could make with each one, justifying your choice with a property of the material.
Define in your own words and give an example of each of these material properties: hardness, electrical conductivity, and density.
Define in your own words and give an example of each of these material properties: hardness, electrical conductivity, and density.
Match each object with the property of the material that makes it possible: (a) a window, (b) a copper wire, (c) a hammer, (d) a raincoat. Properties: conductivity,…
Match each object with the property of the material that makes it possible: (a) a window, (b) a copper wire, (c) a hammer, (d) a raincoat. Properties: conductivity, hardness, waterproofing, and transparency. Justify each pair in one sentence.
Classify these objects according to their main material (wood, metal, plastic, ceramic, or textile): a frying pan, a plant pot, a T-shirt, a transparent ruler, and a…
Classify these objects according to their main material (wood, metal, plastic, ceramic, or textile): a frying pan, a plant pot, a T-shirt, a transparent ruler, and a pencil.
Explain the difference between a mechanical property (such as hardness or elasticity) and a thermal or electrical property (such as conductivity), with an example of…
Explain the difference between a mechanical property (such as hardness or elasticity) and a thermal or electrical property (such as conductivity), with an example of each type.
What property makes cork a good bottle stopper and rubber a good material for tyres? Name the property in each case and explain it in one sentence.
What property makes cork a good bottle stopper and rubber a good material for tyres? Name the property in each case and explain it in one sentence.
State whether these statements are true or false and correct the false ones: (a) all metals are attracted to a magnet, (b) glass is an electrical insulator, (c) dry wood…
State whether these statements are true or false and correct the false ones: (a) all metals are attracted to a magnet, (b) glass is an electrical insulator, (c) dry wood conducts electricity well.
Choosing Based on Compared Properties
Each object demands a different combination of properties, and the material is chosen by comparing the alternatives.
Besides technical properties, good criteria also include the origin and disposal of the material, the cost, and whether it is available in the region: clay, local wood, bamboo, natural fibers, or recycled PET. A material that can be found nearby and can be reused or recycled harms the community's surroundings less.
Name an everyday object made from recycled or clearly recyclable material and explain the advantage of choosing it.
Name an everyday object made from recycled or clearly recyclable material and explain the advantage of choosing it.
To build a garden bench that will always be outdoors, compare wood and steel across at least three relevant properties and decide which you would choose, justifying your…
To build a garden bench that will always be outdoors, compare wood and steel across at least three relevant properties and decide which you would choose, justifying your decision.
The graph compares the density of three workshop materials. For a school drone frame, it needs to be as lightweight as possible while remaining rigid. Using the data in…
The graph compares the density of three workshop materials. For a school drone frame, it needs to be as lightweight as possible while remaining rigid. Using the data in the graph, explain which material you would choose and what other property you would check before deciding.
The handles of pots and frying pans are made of plastic or wood, never the same metal as the body. Explain this design decision using at least two material properties.
The handles of pots and frying pans are made of plastic or wood, never the same metal as the body. Explain this design decision using at least two material properties.
The same chair can be made from pine, steel, or polypropylene. Create a comparison table with three relevant properties and decide which you would choose for a school…
The same chair can be made from pine, steel, or polypropylene. Create a comparison table with three relevant properties and decide which you would choose for a school canteen, justifying your choice.
Choose a material for each of these items and justify it with a key property, also ruling out an alternative that seems valid: the bottom of an aquarium, a fridge…
Choose a material for each of these items and justify it with a key property, also ruling out an alternative that seems valid: the bottom of an aquarium, a fridge magnet, and the handle of a kettle.
The plastic hinges on a locker break after a few months of use. Analyse which property was ignored when choosing that material, what alternative material you would…
The plastic hinges on a locker break after a few months of use. Analyse which property was ignored when choosing that material, what alternative material you would propose, and why.
A solar garden light has several parts: the post, the solar panel housing, the shade protecting the light, and the internal battery holder. Choose a specific material…
A solar garden light has several parts: the post, the solar panel housing, the shade protecting the light, and the internal battery holder. Choose a specific material for each part and justify each choice using a property.
A child's toy must be non-toxic, bite-resistant, washable, and lightweight. Analyse which materials would meet all the requirements and what trade-offs each possible…
A child's toy must be non-toxic, bite-resistant, washable, and lightweight. Analyse which materials would meet all the requirements and what trade-offs each possible option involves.
Testing and Comparing: A Fair Hardness Test
Before deciding, it is sometimes worth checking a property in the shop. For the result to be useful, the comparison has to be fair: only the material should change.
Design a simple workshop experiment to compare the hardness of three materials (pine wood, plastic and aluminum): procedure, which variable is measured and how to ensure…
Design a simple workshop experiment to compare the hardness of three materials (pine wood, plastic and aluminum): procedure, which variable is measured and how to ensure the comparison is fair.
Composite Materials and Protective Layers
When no single material meets all the requirements, two are combined to add up their strengths.
The handle of a screwdriver combines hard plastic with rubberised areas. Explain what properties each material provides and why the handle is not made entirely of steel…
The handle of a screwdriver combines hard plastic with rubberised areas. Explain what properties each material provides and why the handle is not made entirely of steel like the shaft.
Explain what a composite material is using the example of reinforced concrete or fibreglass: what each component provides and why the combination improves upon the…
Explain what a composite material is using the example of reinforced concrete or fibreglass: what each component provides and why the combination improves upon the materials separately.
A team chooses aluminum for an outdoor structure 'because it does not rust'. Qualify this statement: what actually happens to aluminum when exposed to air and why that…
A team chooses aluminum for an outdoor structure 'because it does not rust'. Qualify this statement: what actually happens to aluminum when exposed to air and why that ultimately protects it.
Investigate what Corten steel is and why it is used in unpainted outdoor sculptures. Relate it to the idea of a "protective layer" and compare it with the solution of…
Investigate what Corten steel is and why it is used in unpainted outdoor sculptures. Relate it to the idea of a "protective layer" and compare it with the solution of painting steel every few years.
Deciding with Technical, Social, and Environmental Criteria
Choosing among several valid options requires comparing and recognizing which disadvantage is being accepted.
A common dilemma: bioplastic or recycled plastic. Bioplastic comes from plant-based raw material, but it doesn't always break down in a landfill and can contaminate regular recycling. Recycled plastic (like PET) reduces waste, but it degrades after several rounds of recycling. You choose by acknowledging the weakness of the option.
A material must be chosen for a reusable bottle for a school bag. Evaluate stainless steel, plastic, and glass based on weight, impact resistance, hygiene, and cost;…
A material must be chosen for a reusable bottle for a school bag. Evaluate stainless steel, plastic, and glass based on weight, impact resistance, hygiene, and cost; choose one and justify your decision, acknowledging which disadvantages you accept.
A yoghurt pot combines several materials (plastic pot, aluminum lid, label). Analyse why the use of multiple materials complicates its recycling and propose a redesign…
A yoghurt pot combines several materials (plastic pot, aluminum lid, label). Analyse why the use of multiple materials complicates its recycling and propose a redesign that avoids it.
Evaluate the "bioplastic versus recycled plastic" dilemma for manufacturing a bottle: raw material origin, degradation and recyclability. Defend one option while…
Evaluate the "bioplastic versus recycled plastic" dilemma for manufacturing a bottle: raw material origin, degradation and recyclability. Defend one option while acknowledging its weaknesses.
Back to the beginning: the frying pan needs a body that conducts heat well and a handle that doesn't, so no single material works for both functions: different materials are combined. The outdoor bench has to withstand rain and sun, and it is chosen by comparing properties, cost, and disposal.