Back to homeTechnology · Secondary Year 3 · Change subject
Start for free
Secondary 3 · Technology
The technology project · Products, materials, and manufacturing

Manufacturing Techniques

For your school's science and technology fair, you need 40 wooden keychains with the school crest. You could make them with a saw and a file, with a machine, or with a 3D printer. Which one is best? No technique is always the best: each has its own area where it works well, and choosing well saves time, material, and money. At the end of the page we come back to this problem.

Handcrafted and factory manufacturing

An alebrije from San Martín Tilcajete is carved by hand, one piece at a time. The tortillas from a factory come out by the thousands on a line of machines. Both ways are valid, but they work differently.

Handcrafted Factory
Who does the work The person, with simple tools Machines, with people who operate them
Pieces One or a few, each slightly different Many, almost identical
Example Black clay pottery of Oaxaca, talavera of Puebla Brickyard with machinery, bottling plant
Practice★☆☆Not started
Explain the difference between manual manufacturing and mechanical manufacturing (using machine tools), and give an example of a product made with each.

Explain the difference between manual manufacturing and mechanical manufacturing (using machine tools), and give an example of a product made with each.

Solve

Manual and machine techniques

The first technical distinction is who carries out the operation: the hand, guided by a simple tool, or a machine tool. Tools are an extension of your body: the saw extends your hand, and the drill makes a hole that your hand alone could not make.

Four shop operations with their tool: sawing with a saw, drilling with a drill, sanding with sandpaper, and driving screws with a screwdriver. sawing drilling sanding driving screws saw drill sandpaper screwdriver

Each operation has its tool, and choosing the right one is also a matter of safety.

When the same piece has to be repeated several times, a template helps: a physical guide for marking or cutting every piece the same.

Practice★☆☆Not started
Name the appropriate tool for each operation: sawing a wooden strip, drilling a sheet of metal, sanding an edge and screwing two parts together.

Name the appropriate tool for each operation: sawing a wooden strip, drilling a sheet of metal, sanding an edge and screwing two parts together.

Solve
Practice★☆☆Not started
Explain what a template in manufacturing is and why it saves time and prevents errors when making several identical parts.

Explain what a template in manufacturing is and why it saves time and prevents errors when making several identical parts.

Solve
Practice★☆☆Not started
Write two workshop safety rules (safety goggles, tied-back hair, machine guards...) and explain what specific accident each one prevents.

Write two workshop safety rules (safety goggles, tied-back hair, machine guards...) and explain what specific accident each one prevents.

Solve

Order of operations

The order matters. For a simple wooden frame: mark the measurements, cut to size, sand, dry-fit the pieces without glue to check that they fit together, and finally glue. Checking before gluing lets you correct mistakes; after gluing you can't.

Practice★☆☆Not started
Put the operations for manufacturing a simple wooden frame in order: gluing, cutting to size, sanding, marking the measurements and dry-fitting the parts to check them.

Put the operations for manufacturing a simple wooden frame in order: gluing, cutting to size, sanding, marking the measurements and dry-fitting the parts to check them.

Solve

Subtractive, additive, and digital manufacturing

Digital manufacturing is manufacturing that uses a computer-made model to control a machine. In a classroom workshop the most common machines are the 3D printer (deposits melted plastic layer by layer) and the laser cutter (cuts or engraves sheets following a drawing).

Additive manufacturing process: a 3D model of a vase is sliced into horizontal layers, the printer deposits the material layer by layer, and the finished piece is obtained. 3D design slice print layer by layer piece the body is built by adding material

The stages are: design the 3D model, slice it (the slicer program cuts it into layers and generates the instructions), print layer by layer, and, at the end, remove the piece and finish it.

Practice★☆☆Not started
The image shows a 3D printer manufacturing a part, with its elements numbered. Identify each element and explain in your own words how the printer builds the object,…

The image shows a 3D printer manufacturing a part, with its elements numbered. Identify each element and explain in your own words how the printer builds the object, layer by layer.

Filament 3D printer manufacturing a part, with its elements numbered

Solve
Practice★☆☆Not started
Explain what digital manufacturing is and name two common machines in a workshop classroom that enable it, stating what each one does.

Explain what digital manufacturing is and name two common machines in a workshop classroom that enable it, stating what each one does.

Solve
Practice★☆☆Not started
Explain what "additive" manufacturing means and how it differs from "subtractive" manufacturing (saw, drill, milling machine), giving an example of each.

Explain what "additive" manufacturing means and how it differs from "subtractive" manufacturing (saw, drill, milling machine), giving an example of each.

Solve
Practice★★☆Not started
The figure summarises the manufacturing process of a part by 3D printing, but one step is missing. State which step it is and what is done in it.

The figure summarises the manufacturing process of a part by 3D printing, but one step is missing. State which step it is and what is done in it.

3D design ? Printing layer by layer Finished part
Solve

3D printing parameters

Practice★★☆Not started
In 3D printing, explain what "layer height" and "infill" are, and how each parameter affects the printing time and the strength of the part.

In 3D printing, explain what "layer height" and "infill" are, and how each parameter affects the printing time and the strength of the part.

Solve
Practice★★☆Not started
A 3D-printed part detaches from the print bed halfway through printing and becomes unusable. Analyse two common causes (poor first-layer adhesion, draughts) and how to…

A 3D-printed part detaches from the print bed halfway through printing and becomes unusable. Analyse two common causes (poor first-layer adhesion, draughts) and how to prevent each one.

Solve

Heat bending of acrylic

Acrylic (plexiglass) is bent by heating it. In the shop, a strip heater (a hot wire) or a heat gun is used. You mark the bend line, heat only that strip until the sheet softens (it feels flexible, with no bubbles), bend it with the help of a square or guide, and hold it until it cools.

Precautions: wear heat-resistant gloves and safety glasses, work with ventilation, don't overheat (bubbles appear and the material warps), and don't touch the heating element. To cut it, use a fine-toothed blade and moderate speed, so it doesn't chip.

Practice★★☆Not started
Describe the heat bending process of acrylic (perspex): what equipment is used in the workshop, how the sheet is heated and bent, and what safety precautions must be…

Describe the heat bending process of acrylic (perspex): what equipment is used in the workshop, how the sheet is heated and bent, and what safety precautions must be taken.

Solve

Choosing the technique based on number of parts, shape, and precision

There is no one best technique in every case: the choice depends on how many identical pieces are needed, how complicated the shape is, and the precision required.

Technique selection chart: 3D printing sits in short runs of complex shapes and laser cutting in runs with many identical pieces and flat shapes. high low few many number of identical pieces shape complexity 3D printing laser cutting / series

Scroll saw versus laser cutting

For a 3 mm wooden plate with tight curves, compare as follows:

Criterion Scroll saw Laser cutting
Precision Depends on the steadiness of the person cutting; each piece comes out slightly different Follows the digital drawing; all pieces come out almost identical
Speed Slow: several minutes per piece Fast: seconds per piece, once the file is prepared
Edge finish Needs sanding; may splinter Clean edge, slightly darkened (burned)

For 40 identical pieces with tight curves, the laser is the better choice: the precision and speed are repeated in every piece. The scroll saw is good for one or two pieces, when there is no laser or when preparing the file isn't worth it.

Different techniques, different impacts

For a batch of plastic housings there are two paths. Injection molding melts plastic and injects it into a metal mold: the mold is expensive and is made once, but afterward each piece comes out in seconds, with little energy and little waste per unit. FDM 3D printing needs no mold, but each piece takes hours. Its advantage is that it can be printed near the customer, on demand, which saves transportation and avoids overproduction.

Criterion Injection (distant plant) 3D printing (near the customer)
Energy per unit Low if the run is large High per piece
Material waste Some (sprues and rejected pieces) Little; almost all is used, with supports
Transportation Long, from the plant to the customer Short or none
Initial cost High (the mold) Almost none

With 50,000 identical pieces, injection wins: the mold cost is spread over many pieces and the energy per unit is much lower. With 25 custom spare parts, 3D printing wins: an expensive mold isn't justified for so few pieces. The threshold is where the mold cost, divided among the pieces, is already less than the cost of printing them one by one. For a complete analysis of energy, waste, and transportation, see the section on the life cycle of a product.

Tolerance and precision

Tolerance is not a defect that has to be eliminated: no machine gives a perfect measurement. Asking for high precision (for example 0.1 mm) requires better tools, more adjustment time, and more care, and that raises the cost. In a school workshop, a well-calibrated 3D printer and laser cutter come close to that precision; a hand saw and a file do not.

Practice★★☆Not started
Choose the most suitable manufacturing technique for each case and justify it: (a) a single prototype of a complex-shaped part, (b) one thousand identical metal washers,…

Choose the most suitable manufacturing technique for each case and justify it: (a) a single prototype of a complex-shaped part, (b) one thousand identical metal washers, (c) a hand-carved wooden sign.

Solve
Practice★★☆Not started
To manufacture the flat parts of a scale model, your team is torn between 3D printing and laser cutting. Compare both techniques for that specific job and explain which…

To manufacture the flat parts of a scale model, your team is torn between 3D printing and laser cutting. Compare both techniques for that specific job and explain which one you would choose.

Solve
Practice★★☆Not started
When cutting parts that must fit together, you work with a margin or tolerance. Explain what that means and what happens if one part is cut at the upper limit of the…

When cutting parts that must fit together, you work with a margin or tolerance. Explain what that means and what happens if one part is cut at the upper limit of the tolerance range and the other at the lower limit.

Solve
Practice★★☆Not started
Compare cutting a $3\ \text{mm}$ wooden board using a fretsaw and laser cutting: precision, speed and edge finish. Which would you choose for 40 identical parts with…

Compare cutting a $3\ \text{mm}$ wooden board using a fretsaw and laser cutting: precision, speed and edge finish. Which would you choose for 40 identical parts with tight curves?

Solve
Practice★★★Not started
In the workshop, you want to make 20 metal reinforcing brackets ($50\times 50\times 3\text{ mm}$) and a cylindrical shaft of revolution with two stepped diameters for a…

In the workshop, you want to make 20 metal reinforcing brackets ($50\times 50\times 3\text{ mm}$) and a cylindrical shaft of revolution with two stepped diameters for a pulley. A classmate suggests 3D printing both parts in PLA to "avoid getting tired with hand tools". Refute their proposal technically: predict what mechanical or functional failures each printed part will present compared to one made with traditional techniques (sheet metal forming/machining and lathe) and justify which traditional technique is appropriate in each case.

Solve
Practice★★★Not started
You are going to make a headphone stand from a flat sheet of $4\text{ mm}$ acrylic (PMMA) using cutting and thermal forming (bending). During the first tests in the…

You are going to make a headphone stand from a flat sheet of $4\text{ mm}$ acrylic (PMMA) using cutting and thermal forming (bending). During the first tests in the workshop, the material chipped when cut with the jigsaw, and bubbles and irregular deformations appeared on the bend line. Diagnose the technical causes of both failures and design a corrected process sheet, justifying the critical parameters (type of blade and cutting speed, temperature, and bending radius) to ensure an optimal and strong finish.

Solve
Practice★★★Not started
A company is debating whether to manufacture a batch of plastic casings using centralized injection molding at a great distance or using distributed on-demand FDM 3D…

A company is debating whether to manufacture a batch of plastic casings using centralized injection molding at a great distance or using distributed on-demand FDM 3D printing close to the customer. Analyze the life cycle of both options by comparing the energy consumed per unit, material waste, and transport. Predict how the most sustainable option changes if the production run is $50,000$ identical units compared to if only $25$ customized spare parts are required, justifying the feasibility threshold of each technology.

Solve
Practice★★★Not started
Analyze why additive manufacturing generates very little material waste but can consume a lot of energy and time. Compare it with laser cutting for making 100 identical…

Analyze why additive manufacturing generates very little material waste but can consume a lot of energy and time. Compare it with laser cutting for making 100 identical flat parts and explain which one you would choose.

Solve
Practice★★★Not started
A group proposes building a gearbox where two steel shafts must rotate supported directly on holes drilled by hand into the sides of a plywood box, requiring a tolerance…

A group proposes building a gearbox where two steel shafts must rotate supported directly on holes drilled by hand into the sides of a plywood box, requiring a tolerance of $\pm 0.05\text{ mm}$ for the gears to mesh perfectly.

  1. a) Justify why it is technically unfeasible to achieve and maintain that tolerance in the school workshop using wood and hand tools (consider both the limitations of machining and the hygrometric behavior of the material).
  2. b) Redesign the constructive solution by proposing which commercial components or design modifications would allow the mechanism to operate precisely without requiring unattainable manufacturing means.
Solve

Planning a production run and quality control

Making more than one piece requires organizing the work by stations and checking the result while production is under way. This also protects effectiveness (that the pieces meet what was requested) and reliability (that they come out right again and again).

Keychain manufacturing line with four stations and a bar chart: sanding, at 3 minutes per piece, is the slowest station and sets the pace. cutting drilling sanding finishing 1 min/piece 1.5 min/piece 3 min/piece 1 min/piece The slowest station sets the pace of the whole line
Practice★★★Not started
In the workshop, you must produce a batch of 40 wooden keychains in a 90-minute session. The process consists of four successive stations with one student per station:…

In the workshop, you must produce a batch of 40 wooden keychains in a 90-minute session. The process consists of four successive stations with one student per station: Marking and cutting ($3\text{ min/unit}$), Drilling ($1\text{ min/unit}$), Sanding ($4\text{ min/unit}$), and Varnishing ($1.5\text{ min/unit}$).

  1. a) Identify the current bottleneck and calculate how many complete units you will actually be able to finish in the available time.
  2. b) Design a redistribution of tasks or resources to balance the line so that you reach the 40 units without causing intermediate accumulation of parts, justifying the new cycle times.
Solve
Practice★★★Not started
During the quality control of a batch of 50 3D-printed parts with a hole that must measure exactly $20.0\text{ mm}$ (permissible tolerance $\pm 0.15\text{ mm}$), you…

During the quality control of a batch of 50 3D-printed parts with a hole that must measure exactly $20.0\text{ mm}$ (permissible tolerance $\pm 0.15\text{ mm}$), you measure the first 5 and obtain: $19.65\text{ mm}$, $19.70\text{ mm}$, $19.65\text{ mm}$, $19.68\text{ mm}$, and $19.67\text{ mm}$.

  1. a) Interpret the data: is it a random or a systematic error? Diagnose two possible causes linked to the thermal shrinkage of the plastic or to the slicer (slicer) configuration.
  2. b) Design an action plan: what adjustment must you apply before resuming the production run, and what criteria will you follow to decide whether the already manufactured parts are scrapped or can be reworked.
Solve

Make it yourself or buy it ready-made

A wall shelf costs $\$250$ at a hardware store. Is it better to make it yourself? It depends on how much it really costs to make it.

It is worth making it yourself when you already have the tools, you want a special size or design, or the goal is to learn. It is worth buying it ready-made when you need the piece soon, you would have to buy expensive tools for a single use, or the required quality (strength, precision) is hard to achieve in your shop.

Practice★★★Not started
To organize workshop components, you need a wall-mounted sorting cabinet. A commercial laminated particle board kit costs $\$38…

To organize workshop components, you need a wall-mounted sorting cabinet. A commercial laminated particle board kit costs $\$38$. Manufacturing it yourself using plywood costs $\$30$ in wood, $\$6$ in screws and adhesive, requires buying a basic palm router ($\$42$), and entails 8 hours of workshop labor.

  1. a) Perform a comparative analysis of immediate and amortized costs (considering the tool's life cycle and the durability of the materials).
  2. b) Technically justify under what conditions (dimensional customization, moisture resistance, repairability, or future production volume) self-manufacturing pays off compared to buying the standard kit.
Solve

Back to the beginning: for 40 wooden keychains with the school crest, laser cutting or a template with a saw gives identical pieces quickly, and a line by stations with reinforced sanding keeps pieces from piling up. 3D printing would be slow for so many flat pieces.

Summary

See all the exercises in this section