Lewis Diagrams, Resonance, and Formal Charge
A formula like $\mathrm{CO_2}$ tells you which atoms are present, but not how the electrons are shared or what shape the molecule has. A Lewis diagram is the first map of that sharing: dots and lines that, when built correctly, predict bonds, lone pairs, and even chemical behavior. By the end of this page you will also be able to explain why the two N–O bonds in a nitrite ion are exactly the same length, even though a single Lewis diagram shows one single and one double bond.
Valence electrons and the octet rule
Noble gases form almost no compounds, while most other elements gain, lose, or share electrons until they reach the same outer-shell arrangement. Why does having eight electrons around an atom make it so stable?
Consider the neutral molecules of water ($\mathrm{H_2O}$) and ammonia ($\mathrm{NH_3}$). Data: atomic numbers $Z(\mathrm{H}) = 1$, $Z(\mathrm{N}) = 7$,…
Consider the neutral molecules of water ($\mathrm{H_2O}$) and ammonia ($\mathrm{NH_3}$). Data: atomic numbers $Z(\mathrm{H}) = 1$, $Z(\mathrm{N}) = 7$, $Z(\mathrm{O}) = 8$.
- a) Determine the total number of valence electrons in each molecule and draw their corresponding Lewis structures.
- b) State, giving reasons, how many bonding pairs and how many non-bonding (lone) pairs of electrons the central atom has in each, justifying whether the octet and duet rules are satisfied.
Building a Lewis diagram
Formal charge
For many species, such as the thiocyanate ion ($\mathrm{SCN^-}$), you can draw several Lewis diagrams in which every atom has an octet. How do you decide which one best describes the real species?
In aqueous solution, soluble carbonates release the polyatomic anion $\mathrm{CO_3^{2-}}$. Data: atomic numbers $Z(\mathrm{C}) = 6$, $Z(\mathrm{O}) = 8$. The following…
In aqueous solution, soluble carbonates release the polyatomic anion $\mathrm{CO_3^{2-}}$. Data: atomic numbers $Z(\mathrm{C}) = 6$, $Z(\mathrm{O}) = 8$. The following diagram shows the basic nuclear skeleton of this species:
- a) On paper, complete the Lewis structure for the ion $\mathrm{CO_3^{2-}}$ by distributing the $24$ total valence electrons, and draw the three equivalent resonance structures.
- b) Calculate the formal charge of each atom in one of the resonance structures and briefly explain why resonance is not a real physical oscillation between single and double bonds.
You can do this on paper and send a photo with your answer.
The ammonium cation ($\mathrm{NH_4^+}$) forms when neutral ammonia reacts with a hydrogen ion ($\mathrm{H^+}$). Data: atomic numbers $Z(\mathrm{H}) = 1$,…
The ammonium cation ($\mathrm{NH_4^+}$) forms when neutral ammonia reacts with a hydrogen ion ($\mathrm{H^+}$). Data: atomic numbers $Z(\mathrm{H}) = 1$, $Z(\mathrm{N}) = 7$.
- a) Draw the Lewis structure of the cation $\mathrm{NH_4^+}$, identify the type of bond by which the additional proton is incorporated and justify whether the four $\mathrm{N\text{--}H}$ bonds in the resulting cation are indistinguishable.
- b) Calculate the formal charge of the nitrogen atom and of each hydrogen atom in the ion $\mathrm{NH_4^+}$, comparing it with the formal charge of nitrogen in the $\mathrm{NH_3}$ molecule.
You can do this on paper and send a photo with your answer.
Resonance, bond order, and bond length
The cyanate anion ($\mathrm{OCN^-}$) is a linear species whose nuclear skeleton has carbon as the central atom: $\mathrm{[O\text{--}C\text{--}N]^-}$. Data: atomic…
The cyanate anion ($\mathrm{OCN^-}$) is a linear species whose nuclear skeleton has carbon as the central atom: $\mathrm{[O\text{--}C\text{--}N]^-}$. Data: atomic numbers $Z(\mathrm{C}) = 6$, $Z(\mathrm{N}) = 7$, $Z(\mathrm{O}) = 8$; Pauling electronegativities: $\chi(\mathrm{C}) = 2.55$, $\chi(\mathrm{N}) = 3.04$, $\chi(\mathrm{O}) = 3.44$.
- a) Draw three non-equivalent resonance Lewis structures for the ion $\mathrm{OCN^-}$ in which all atoms complete the octet.
- b) Calculate the formal charges of each atom in the three structures and explain which of them makes the greatest contribution to the resonance hybrid, and which turns out to be the least favorable.
You can do this on paper and send a photo with your answer.
The nitrite anion ($\mathrm{NO_2^-}$) takes part in biogeochemical processes in soil. Data: atomic numbers $Z(\mathrm{N}) = 7$, $Z(\mathrm{O}) = 8$. Experimental bond…
The nitrite anion ($\mathrm{NO_2^-}$) takes part in biogeochemical processes in soil. Data: atomic numbers $Z(\mathrm{N}) = 7$, $Z(\mathrm{O}) = 8$. Experimental bond lengths: typical $\mathrm{N\text{--}O}$ single bond: $140\,\text{pm}$; typical $\mathrm{N=O}$ double bond: $120\,\text{pm}$. X-ray crystallography reveals that in the nitrite ion the two nitrogen–oxygen bonds are identical and measure $124\,\text{pm}$.
- a) Draw the two resonance Lewis structures of the ion $\mathrm{NO_2^-}$, indicating the lone pairs and formal charges of each atom.
- b) Deduce the theoretical average bond order in the resonance hybrid, correlate it with the observed experimental length and rigorously refute the mistaken idea that the molecule oscillates periodically between a single and a double bond. Do not assume an exact linear relationship between bond order and bond length.
You can do this on paper and send a photo with your answer.
Ozone ($\mathrm{O_3}$) has distinctive physicochemical properties. Data: atomic number $Z(\mathrm{O}) = 8$. Experimental $\mathrm{O\text{--}O}$ bond lengths: in hydrogen…
Ozone ($\mathrm{O_3}$) has distinctive physicochemical properties. Data: atomic number $Z(\mathrm{O}) = 8$. Experimental $\mathrm{O\text{--}O}$ bond lengths: in hydrogen peroxide ($\mathrm{H_2O_2}$) it is $148\,\text{pm}$; in molecular dioxygen ($\mathrm{O_2}$) it is $121\,\text{pm}$; in ozone, both $\mathrm{O\text{--}O}$ bonds are equivalent with a length of $128\,\text{pm}$, an angle of $117^\circ$ and a permanent dipole moment of $\mu = 0.53\,\text{D}$.
- a) Write the two resonance Lewis forms of $\mathrm{O_3}$, deducing the formal charges for the central oxygen atom and for the two terminal atoms.
- b) Calculate the average bond order, check that it is consistent with the interatomic distances given, and explain why a homonuclear molecule such as ozone has a non-zero net dipole moment. Do not assume an exact linear relationship between bond order and bond length.
Exceptions to the octet rule
Experiments show that boron trifluoride, $\mathrm{BF_3}$, is a stable neutral molecule with three identical bonds, even though the central boron has only six electrons around it. Why do stable compounds exist that do not complete an octet?
Boron trifluoride ($\mathrm{BF_3}$) is a gaseous reagent frequently used as a catalyst in organic synthesis. Data: atomic numbers $Z(\mathrm{B}) = 5$,…
Boron trifluoride ($\mathrm{BF_3}$) is a gaseous reagent frequently used as a catalyst in organic synthesis. Data: atomic numbers $Z(\mathrm{B}) = 5$, $Z(\mathrm{F}) = 9$.
- a) Draw the Lewis structure of $\mathrm{BF_3}$ in which the three fluorine atoms form single bonds with the central boron atom and complete their respective octets.
- b) Justify why the central boron atom is an exception to the octet rule (electron deficiency) and state the number of bonding and non-bonding pairs this atom has.
You can do this on paper and send a photo with your answer.
The marked electron deficiency of boron trifluoride gives it a high affinity for Lewis bases. When $\mathrm{BF_3}$ reacts with ammonia gas ($\mathrm{NH_3}$), the solid…
The marked electron deficiency of boron trifluoride gives it a high affinity for Lewis bases. When $\mathrm{BF_3}$ reacts with ammonia gas ($\mathrm{NH_3}$), the solid addition adduct $\mathrm{F_3B\text{--}NH_3}$ is formed. Data: atomic numbers $Z(\mathrm{H}) = 1$, $Z(\mathrm{B}) = 5$, $Z(\mathrm{N}) = 7$, $Z(\mathrm{F}) = 9$.
- a) Draw the Lewis structures of the two individual reactants and of the adduct $\mathrm{F_3B\text{--}NH_3}$, specifying which is the donor atom and which is the acceptor in forming the boron–nitrogen bond.
- b) Calculate the formal charges of boron and nitrogen in the isolated reactants and in the final product. From the results, explain how the fulfillment of the octet rule for boron changes after the reaction.
Potential energy and bond length
Why does a bond have a particular length? Picture two atoms approaching each other. Far apart, they barely interact. As they come closer, attraction lowers the potential energy. Closer still, nucleus-nucleus and electron-electron repulsion rise steeply.
The attraction between nuclei and electrons and the repulsion between like charges both follow Coulomb's law, and the balance between them sets the position of the minimum. The minimum of the curve is the bond length. The depth of the well, measured from zero energy (widely separated atoms) down to the minimum, is the bond energy, the energy needed to pull the atoms apart. Higher bond order gives a deeper well at a shorter distance.
Back to the start of the page: a Lewis diagram gives you the electron count, the bonds, and the lone pairs. Resonance and bond order explain why the two N–O bonds in nitrite are equal, and formal charge helps you pick the best diagram.