Material Properties
At a street market, Don Ernesto sells hammers with a steel head and a wooden handle. It's no accident: each part needs something different, and whoever makes tools chooses the material by looking at its technological characteristics, also called properties. Let's get to know them one by one.
Four families of properties
Other characteristics that can be checked with simple tests
Besides the four families, there are characteristics that can be found out with a very simple test and that help identify or choose a material. Three of them appear in the exercises:
-
Magnetism: is it attracted by a magnet? Iron and ordinary steel are; aluminum, copper, plastic, and stainless steel (most kinds) are not.
-
Waterproofing: does it let water through? A waterproof fabric, a plastic, or rubber won't let it through; paper or a sponge absorbs it. You test it by dropping a few drops on it.
-
Passage of waves (like those of Wi-Fi or cell phones): plastics let them through well; metals block or weaken them. You can tell by the signal on the device.
These are useful clues: if an object shines like metal but a magnet doesn't attract it, it isn't iron or ordinary steel.
Sensory properties are perceived through the senses. Describe the color, luster and texture of three objects in your classroom (the desk, a ruler, the whiteboard) and…
Sensory properties are perceived through the senses. Describe the color, luster and texture of three objects in your classroom (the desk, a ruler, the whiteboard) and explain which sense you use to identify each of those properties.
Classify these properties into mechanical, thermal, electrical or sensory: hardness, thermal conductivity, luster, elasticity, electrical conductivity, color. Then give…
Classify these properties into mechanical, thermal, electrical or sensory: hardness, thermal conductivity, luster, elasticity, electrical conductivity, color. Then give an example of an object in which each one is the key property.
You are given a mystery object: it shines like a metal, is quite heavy, cannot be scratched with a fingernail, and is not attracted by a magnet. Reason what material it…
You are given a mystery object: it shines like a metal, is quite heavy, cannot be scratched with a fingernail, and is not attracted by a magnet. Reason what material it could be (stainless steel? aluminum? ceramic?) and design two more tests to find out without breaking it.
Hardness and elasticity
A hardness scale orders materials from least hard to hardest. In the figure, the name of one is missing: to fill it in, compare it with its neighbors (which material scratches wood but is scratched by steel?).
The figure shows a hardness scale with several materials ordered from softest to hardest, but one of them has lost its name, as shown in the diagram. Which material that…
The figure shows a hardness scale with several materials ordered from softest to hardest, but one of them has lost its name, as shown in the diagram.
Which material that you know could fill the gap? Reason your answer by comparing it with its neighbors on the scale, and then place two other materials on the scale: your fingernail and diamond.
A copper coin scratches plaster, but does not scratch steel; a fingernail scratches plaster, but does not scratch the coin. Order these four materials from least to most…
A copper coin scratches plaster, but does not scratch steel; a fingernail scratches plaster, but does not scratch the coin. Order these four materials from least to most hard and explain what simple test you have used to order them (the "scratch test").
Glass is very hard (it hardly scratches at all), but it breaks if dropped on the floor. Explain the difference between hardness and brittleness using this example, and…
Glass is very hard (it hardly scratches at all), but it breaks if dropped on the floor. Explain the difference between hardness and brittleness using this example, and name another hard and brittle material, as well as one that is soft but hard to break.
Design a workshop experiment to order three materials (pine wood, aluminum and a stone) by hardness, using only the materials themselves to scratch each other. Explain…
Design a workshop experiment to order three materials (pine wood, aluminum and a stone) by hardness, using only the materials themselves to scratch each other. Explain the procedure, what you would record in each test, and what conclusion you expect to get.
Thermal and electrical conductivity
Classify these materials into electrical conductors and insulators: copper, plastic, dry wood, steel, rubber. Explain why this property determines which material goes…
Classify these materials into electrical conductors and insulators: copper, plastic, dry wood, steel, rubber. Explain why this property determines which material goes inside and which goes outside a cable.
Cooking pots are made of metal, but the handle is usually made of wood or plastic. Explain this using thermal conductivity and reason what would happen with a pot made…
Cooking pots are made of metal, but the handle is usually made of wood or plastic. Explain this using thermal conductivity and reason what would happen with a pot made of a single piece of steel, handle included.
An electrical cable is copper on the inside and plastic on the outside. Explain what property each layer provides and reason what could happen if the cable gets stripped…
An electrical cable is copper on the inside and plastic on the outside. Explain what property each layer provides and reason what could happen if the cable gets stripped and the copper is exposed.
A copper saucepan with a wooden handle costs considerably more than one made entirely of steel. Analyse which properties explain this design (copper spreads heat very…
A copper saucepan with a wooden handle costs considerably more than one made entirely of steel. Analyse which properties explain this design (copper spreads heat very evenly, wood hardly heats up) and reason whether the extra cost is worth it for cooking on a low heat.
Density: heavy or light for its size
Density tells how "heavy" or "light" a material is for the space it takes up. A steel cube weighs much more than a cork cube of the same size: steel is denser.
Match each property with its definition: (a) hardness, (b) elasticity, (c) electrical conductivity, (d) density. Definitions: 1. ability to regain shape after being…
Match each property with its definition: (a) hardness, (b) elasticity, (c) electrical conductivity, (d) density. Definitions: 1. ability to regain shape after being deformed; 2. resistance to being scratched or worn away; 3. ease of allowing electrical current to pass through; 4. ratio between the mass of a material and the volume it occupies.
True or false? Justify each answer: (a) copper is a good electrical conductor; (b) rubber is a very hard material; (c) a piece of steel weighs more than a piece of cork…
True or false? Justify each answer: (a) copper is a good electrical conductor; (b) rubber is a very hard material; (c) a piece of steel weighs more than a piece of cork of the same size because it is denser; (d) glass is an elastic material.
A cork cube and a steel cube of the same size do not weigh the same. Explain which property accounts for this, reason why cork floats in water and steel sinks, and what…
A cork cube and a steel cube of the same size do not weigh the same. Explain which property accounts for this, reason why cork floats in water and steel sinks, and what the density of water has to do with it.
Choosing the right material
No material is the best for everything. Choosing well means comparing the properties an object needs with those each material offers, and also thinking about what is nearby: community materials, their cost, and their effect on the environment.
Community materials
Local materials are usually cheaper, easy to find nearby, and need less transportation. Mexico has many: the clay of the pottery workshops in Oaxaca (hard once fired, brittle under impact, and a good thermal insulator), palm and ixtle (flexible fibers for mats, baskets, and ropes), quarry stone and adobe (heavy, strong, and good heat insulators), and local wood. Using what is nearby is a local, efficient, and sustainable decision.
A decision table
When there are several options and several criteria, a decision table helps you compare in an orderly way. It is made in four steps: choose the criteria that matter, write down the options, score each option on each criterion (1 = poor, 2 = fair, 3 = good), and add up the points.
Which property matters most in each case? (a) a saw blade; (b) the inside of a cable; (c) a ballpoint pen spring; (d) the filling of a winter coat. Justify each answer…
Which property matters most in each case? (a) a saw blade; (b) the inside of a cable; (c) a ballpoint pen spring; (d) the filling of a winter coat. Justify each answer with one sentence.
Choose the material for each part of an umbrella from these options and justify each choice with at least one property: (a) the ribs: flexible fiber or a cookie; (b) the…
Choose the material for each part of an umbrella from these options and justify each choice with at least one property: (a) the ribs: flexible fiber or a cookie; (b) the canopy: waterproof fabric or newspaper; (c) the handle: hard plastic or sponge.
A cell phone casing can be made of plastic or metal. Compare both options considering weight, scratch resistance, and how well they transmit Wi-Fi signals, and state…
A cell phone casing can be made of plastic or metal. Compare both options considering weight, scratch resistance, and how well they transmit Wi-Fi signals, and state which one you would choose with your reasons.
The school wants to buy new chairs for the classroom. Prioritise the three most important properties (strength, light weight so they can be moved easily, ease of…
The school wants to buy new chairs for the classroom. Prioritise the three most important properties (strength, light weight so they can be moved easily, ease of cleaning, comfort, etc.), choose one material for the frame and another for the seat, and explain which materials you rule out and why.
A shop sells steel, aluminum and carbon fiber bicycles. Compare the weight, strength and price of each option and recommend one for: (a) a person who uses it daily to go…
A shop sells steel, aluminum and carbon fiber bicycles. Compare the weight, strength and price of each option and recommend one for: (a) a person who uses it daily to go to school; (b) a competitive cyclist. Justify why your recommendations are different.
'The harder a material is, the better it is for everything.' Evaluate this statement using two counterexamples (a tyre's rubber, a soft phone case, the sole of a shoe)…
'The harder a material is, the better it is for everything.' Evaluate this statement using two counterexamples (a tyre's rubber, a soft phone case, the sole of a shoe) and rephrase it so that it is correct.
You are going to choose the material for a reusable bottle: stainless steel, hard plastic or glass. Create a decision matrix with four criteria (weight, drop resistance,…
You are going to choose the material for a reusable bottle: stainless steel, hard plastic or glass. Create a decision matrix with four criteria (weight, drop resistance, hygiene and taste, price), score each material from 1 to 3, and draw a reasoned conclusion from your table.
You can do it on paper and send a photo with your answer.
Design a test to compare the elasticity of three rubber bands of different thicknesses: what you would measure (how much each stretches when hanging the same weight and…
Design a test to compare the elasticity of three rubber bands of different thicknesses: what you would measure (how much each stretches when hanging the same weight and whether it returns to its original length when the weight is removed), how you would record it, and what you predict will happen. Explain exactly what property you are measuring and how it differs from hardness.
Back to the beginning: the hammer has a steel head because it needs hardness and strength to strike without deforming, and a wooden handle because it is light, absorbs some of the vibrations, and does not conduct heat or electricity.