Systems with a Parameter
A film crew in Los Angeles flies two camera drones along straight paths: $2x + vy = 6$ and $vx + 2y = 6$. The number $v$ depends on the wind. Depending on $v$, the paths could cross at one point, never meet, or be exactly the same path. Problems call this task discussing the system: you describe what happens for every value of $v$, without solving the system value by value.
Three Possible Outcomes
Each equation $ax + by = c$ is a line. Two lines in a plane can only do three things: cross once, stay parallel, or lie on top of each other.
The quickest clue is the slope. Lines with different slopes always cross exactly once. Lines with the same slope are either parallel (different y-intercepts) or the same line (same y-intercept).
Given the following system of linear equations: $3x - 2y = 4$ $x + y = m$ Is there any value of the parameter $m$ for which the system is inconsistent? Justify your…
Given the following system of linear equations:
$3x - 2y = 4$
$x + y = m$
Is there any value of the parameter $m$ for which the system is inconsistent? Justify your answer mathematically.
The Determinant Test
Comparing slopes means dividing by a coefficient that might be zero for some parameter value. There is a cleaner way that never divides.
Slide $m$ below and watch the second line. At $m = -2$ it lands exactly on top of the first one.
Discuss, in terms of the parameter $m$, the following system of linear equations: $x - 2y = 3$ $mx + 4y = -6$
Discuss, in terms of the parameter $m$, the following system of linear equations:
$x - 2y = 3$
$mx + 4y = -6$
In a market study, the supply and demand curves of a technological product are given by a linear system dependent on a tax $t$: $2x - ty = 3$ $tx + 2y = 4$ Discuss the…
In a market study, the supply and demand curves of a technological product are given by a linear system dependent on a tax $t$:
$2x - ty = 3$
$tx + 2y = 4$
Discuss the consistency of the system according to the values of $t$. Can there be a case where no equilibrium point exists (i.e., the system is inconsistent) if $t$ is a real number?
Determine for which values of the parameter $a$ the following system has a unique solution $(x, y)$ such that the point of intersection of both lines lies exactly on the…
Determine for which values of the parameter $a$ the following system has a unique solution $(x, y)$ such that the point of intersection of both lines lies exactly on the y-axis ($x=0$):
$ax + 3y = 6$
$2x - ay = a$
Special Values: Parallel or Same Line?
When you solve $D = 0$, each solution is a special value of the parameter. At that value the lines have equal slopes, and you must decide: same line or parallel?
Sometimes the parameter appears only in a constant, as in $2x - y = a$ and $-4x + 2y = 8$. Then $D = (2)(2) - (-4)(-1) = 0$ for every $a$, so the parameter in the constants decides everything. Make the equations multiples of each other: the second one is $-2 \times (2x - y = -4)$, so you need $a = -4$ for the lines to coincide. For any other $a$ the lines are parallel.
Writing the infinitely many solutions
When a system has infinitely many solutions, the exercise may ask you to describe them all. Both equations say the same thing, so keep just one of them. Solve it for one variable, then call the other variable a free parameter such as $\lambda$ (or $t$), which can be any real number.
Choose as the free variable the one that keeps the other expression free of fractions. If the discussion shows that no value of the parameter gives infinitely many solutions, say so: the answer to "describe the infinite solutions" is then "this never happens."
Determine the value of the parameter $k$ for the following system to be inconsistent: $3x + ky = 5$ $6x - 4y = 2$
Determine the value of the parameter $k$ for the following system to be inconsistent:
$3x + ky = 5$
$6x - 4y = 2$
Find the value of $a$ for the following system to have infinitely many solutions. Write the general solution in that case. $2x - y = a$ $-4x + 2y = 8$
Find the value of $a$ for the following system to have infinitely many solutions. Write the general solution in that case.
$2x - y = a$
$-4x + 2y = 8$
Find the values of the parameter $b$ for which the following system is consistent with a unique solution: $x + by = 2$ $bx + y = 2$
Find the values of the parameter $b$ for which the following system is consistent with a unique solution:
$x + by = 2$
$bx + y = 2$
A Full Discussion, Step by Step
Put the pieces together into one routine you can use on any system with one parameter.
Discuss the following system of equations in terms of the parameter $t$: $tx + y = t$ $x + ty = 1$
Discuss the following system of equations in terms of the parameter $t$:
$tx + y = t$
$x + ty = 1$
Discuss the system dependent on the parameter $c$: $cx - 2y = 1$ $x - cy = 2$
Discuss the system dependent on the parameter $c$:
$cx - 2y = 1$
$x - cy = 2$
Discuss, in terms of the parameter $k$, the following system of equations: $(k+1)x + y = 2$ $kx + (k-1)y = 1$
Discuss, in terms of the parameter $k$, the following system of equations:
$(k+1)x + y = 2$
$kx + (k-1)y = 1$
Discuss the system in terms of the parameter $m$: $x + y = m$ $m^2 x + y = m^2$
Discuss the system in terms of the parameter $m$:
$x + y = m$
$m^2 x + y = m^2$
Two Parameters
Sometimes one parameter sits in the coefficients and another in the constants. The determinant decides whether there is a unique solution (it depends only on the coefficients). The second parameter only matters at the special values.
The picture below shows every pair $(k, n)$. Only two points give infinitely many solutions.
Discuss the following system of linear equations in terms of the parameters $a$ and $b$: $ax + y = b$ $x + ay = 2$
Discuss the following system of linear equations in terms of the parameters $a$ and $b$:
$ax + y = b$
$x + ay = 2$
Discuss the system in terms of the parameters $m$ and $n$: $mx + ny = 1$ $nx + my = 1$ Determine the exact conditions on $m$ and $n$ for the system to be inconsistent.
Discuss the system in terms of the parameters $m$ and $n$:
$mx + ny = 1$
$nx + my = 1$
Determine the exact conditions on $m$ and $n$ for the system to be inconsistent.
Discuss the following system and, in cases where it is consistent with infinitely many solutions, express the infinite solutions in terms of a parameter $\lambda$:…
Discuss the following system and, in cases where it is consistent with infinitely many solutions, express the infinite solutions in terms of a parameter $\lambda$:
$mx + (m+1)y = m$
$mx + 2my = 2$
Lines and Real-World Situations
Each equation of the system is a line, so the three outcomes have a geometric meaning: intersecting (one solution), parallel (none), or coincident (infinitely many). A parameter might stand for wind speed, a concentration, or a resistance. The math is identical; you just state the result in words at the end.
Let's close the hook. The drone paths are $2x + vy = 6$ and $vx + 2y = 6$. The determinant is $D = 4 - v^2 = (2 - v)(2 + v)$, which is zero at $v = 2$ and $v = -2$.
-
For $v \ne \pm 2$ the paths cross at exactly one point.
-
For $v = 2$ both equations become $2x + 2y = 6$, so the drones fly the same path.
-
For $v = -2$ the equations become $x - y = 3$ and $x - y = -3$, so the paths are parallel and never meet.
If the situation only allows $v \ge 0$ (say, wind speed measured as a positive number), then $v = -2$ is not possible. The context can remove cases, but you still discuss the system first and then interpret.
Discuss the relative position of the lines $r: px + 3y = 1$ and $s: 2x + py = 0$ in terms of the parameter $p$.
Discuss the relative position of the lines $r: px + 3y = 1$ and $s: 2x + py = 0$ in terms of the parameter $p$.
Two surveillance drones follow rectilinear trajectories described by the following system, where $v$ is a parameter related to wind speed: $vx + 2y = 4$ $2x + vy = v$…
Two surveillance drones follow rectilinear trajectories described by the following system, where $v$ is a parameter related to wind speed:
$vx + 2y = 4$
$2x + vy = v$
Discuss for which values of $v$ the trajectories of the drones intersect at a single point, are parallel or coincide exactly.
In a chemical plant, two liquid solutions are mixed. The equations that model the mass balance of the process depend on the concentration $c$ of a specific reagent:…
In a chemical plant, two liquid solutions are mixed. The equations that model the mass balance of the process depend on the concentration $c$ of a specific reagent:
$cx + 4y = c^2$
$x + cy = 2$
Discuss the consistency of the system in terms of the concentration $c$.
Two high-voltage cables are modelled in a plane by the lines $r: 2x + (k-2)y = k$ and $s: (k-2)x + 2y = 2$. Discuss the relative position of the cables in terms of the…
Two high-voltage cables are modelled in a plane by the lines $r: 2x + (k-2)y = k$ and $s: (k-2)x + 2y = 2$. Discuss the relative position of the cables in terms of the parameter $k$ to avoid possible short circuits.
Non-Linear Systems with a Parameter
When one equation is a parabola or a circle, there is no determinant. The question becomes: how many intersection points are there? Substitute the line into the other equation and you get a quadratic. Then the discriminant $\Delta = b^2 - 4ac$ decides.
The same plan works for a circle. For $x^2 + y^2 = 5$ and $y = 2x + c$, substitution gives $5x^2 + 4cx + c^2 - 5 = 0$ with $\Delta = 100 - 4c^2$. So there are two points when $|c| < 5$, one point when $|c| = 5$, and none when $|c| > 5$.
The trajectory of a projectile follows a parabola described by the equation $y = -x^2 + 4x$, while a defense laser beam follows the line $y = mx$. Discuss the number of…
The trajectory of a projectile follows a parabola described by the equation $y = -x^2 + 4x$, while a defense laser beam follows the line $y = mx$. Discuss the number of intersection points between the projectile and the laser in terms of the parameter $m$ (which represents the gradient of the laser).
Discuss the consistency of the following non-linear system in terms of the parameter $k$: $x^2 - y^2 = k$ $x + y = 2$
Discuss the consistency of the following non-linear system in terms of the parameter $k$:
$x^2 - y^2 = k$
$x + y = 2$
A satellite orbits following a circular trajectory modeled in the plane by the equation $x^2 + y^2 = 4$. A comet travels in a straight line according to the equation…
A satellite orbits following a circular trajectory modeled in the plane by the equation $x^2 + y^2 = 4$. A comet travels in a straight line according to the equation $x + y = c$, where $c$ is a parameter that depends on its initial position. Discuss the number of collision points between the satellite and the comet in terms of $c$.
Back to the start: the drone paths $2x + vy = 6$ and $vx + 2y = 6$ have $D = 4 - v^2$. They cross at one point unless $v = 2$ (same path) or $v = -2$ (parallel paths that never meet).