Disorders of the immune system
The immune system does not always get it right: it can overreact to something harmless (allergy), mistake self for non-self and attack the body itself (autoimmunity), or fall short and leave the door open to infections that a healthy system would control with no effort (immunodeficiency). Understanding these three failures explains many of today's chronic diseases.
Allergies and hypersensitivity
A grain of pollen on a summer day at Bull Island, or a few milligrams of peanut at a school disco, are completely harmless to most people, but in others they trigger hives, shortness of breath or a collapse in blood pressure within minutes. Why does the immune system mount such a destructive response to substances that pose no real threat?
What is an allergy? Give two examples of common allergens and explain what occurs in the body of an allergic person when they come into contact with them.
What is an allergy? Give two examples of common allergens and explain what occurs in the body of an allergic person when they come into contact with them.
What is histamine and what symptoms does it produce when it is released during an allergic reaction? State how antihistamine drugs act.
What is histamine and what symptoms does it produce when it is released during an allergic reaction? State how antihistamine drugs act.
Asthma is an inflammatory disease of the airways with a frequent allergic component. Explain what happens in the bronchi during an asthma attack and why it is considered…
Asthma is an inflammatory disease of the airways with a frequent allergic component. Explain what happens in the bronchi during an asthma attack and why it is considered a disproportionate immune response.
The diagram represents the activation of a mast cell in a connective tissue at the molecular level. a) Deduce what particles A and molecules B represent. Justify which…
The diagram represents the activation of a mast cell in a connective tissue at the molecular level.
- a) Deduce what particles A and molecules B represent. Justify which isotype the membrane-bound immunoglobulins belong to and which of their regions (Fab or Fc) binds to the mast cell receptor and which to particle A.
- b) A laboratory tests two drugs to prevent allergic crises: Drug 1 (a monoclonal antibody that specifically blocks the free Fc portion of these immunoglobulins before they contact the mast cell) and Drug 2 (a competitive antagonist of the receptors for molecule B). Reasonably predict which of the two drugs would be completely useless if administered to a patient after mast cell degranulation has already begun.
- c) An unsensitized person suffers a wasp sting for the first time in their life. A companion insists on injecting them with emergency adrenaline, claiming that "the venom will cause immediate anaphylactic shock." Based on the immune mechanism in the diagram, refute this claim and justify what critical vascular alteration causes death in true anaphylactic shock if it is not reversed in time.
A student who had never previously shown respiratory problems moves to live in Kilkenny in the month of April. During that first spring, he does not experience any…
A student who had never previously shown respiratory problems moves to live in Kilkenny in the month of April. During that first spring, he does not experience any discomfort. However, in the middle of the following spring, after a walk through a birch wood, he develops severe allergic rhinitis with paroxysmal sneezing, itchy eyes, and rhinorrhoea in less than ten minutes.
- a) The student claims that "his immune system completely ignored the pollen the first year and only learned to attack it in the second year." Refute this statement by deducing which cellular and molecular processes occurred asymptomatically during the first spring (sensitisation stage).
- b) Justify at a molecular and cellular level why in the second year the symptomatic response takes only a few minutes to trigger, comparing the kinetics of this reaction with that of a classic primary adaptive immune response.
- c) If we perform a serological test on this student and a non-atopic friend of his who was walking with him, predict what quantitative and qualitative differences will be observed in total and specific plasma IgE levels for birch pollen antigens, and reason why the friend's mast cells do not undergo degranulation.
Autoimmune diseases
What is an autoimmune disease? Name two examples and explain which immune system malfunction causes them.
What is an autoimmune disease? Name two examples and explain which immune system malfunction causes them.
In type 1 diabetes, the immune system destroys the insulin-producing beta cells of the pancreas. Explain why it is considered an autoimmune disease and account for why…
In type 1 diabetes, the immune system destroys the insulin-producing beta cells of the pancreas. Explain why it is considered an autoimmune disease and account for why its treatment consists of administering insulin.
In systemic lupus erythematosus, autoantibodies are produced against components of the nucleus of one's own cells. Explain what autoantibodies are, why this disease can…
In systemic lupus erythematosus, autoantibodies are produced against components of the nucleus of one's own cells. Explain what autoantibodies are, why this disease can affect several organs at once and why its diagnosis includes the search for antinuclear antibodies in the blood.
In multiple sclerosis, the immune system destroys the myelin that covers the neurons. Reason why it is classified as an autoimmune disease, what immune cells take part…
In multiple sclerosis, the immune system destroys the myelin that covers the neurons. Reason why it is classified as an autoimmune disease, what immune cells take part in the attack and why the symptoms depend on the area of the nervous system affected.
A 50-year-old female patient with severe rheumatoid arthritis does not experience improvement with anti-inflammatory drugs. Her specialist decides to prescribe…
A 50-year-old female patient with severe rheumatoid arthritis does not experience improvement with anti-inflammatory drugs. Her specialist decides to prescribe biological treatment with infliximab, a monoclonal antibody that specifically blocks tumour necrosis factor alpha (TNF-α). Before starting treatment, the hospital protocol mandatorily requires a tuberculin skin test (Mantoux) and a chest X-ray.
- a) Justify the biological mechanism by which the neutralisation of TNF-α succeeds in halting chronic inflammation and articular cartilage destruction in this autoimmune pathology.
- b) Reason why it is essential to rule out a latent Mycobacterium tuberculosis infection before administering infliximab: explain the normal defensive role of TNF-α in the formation and maintenance of the granulomas that confine this intracellular microorganism, and predict what complication would occur if the drug is administered to a person with silent tuberculous infection.
- c) The patient trusts that this biological treatment will "repair her immune system and permanently cure rheumatoid arthritis." Refute this expectation by explaining why the monoclonal antibody acts as a palliative/anti-inflammatory therapy and does not correct the loss of self-tolerance that caused the disease.
In autoimmune diseases such as systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) or Hashimoto's thyroiditis, close to 90% of diagnosed cases correspond to women. To explain this marked…
In autoimmune diseases such as systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) or Hashimoto's thyroiditis, close to 90% of diagnosed cases correspond to women. To explain this marked sex bias, the scientific community investigates hormonal factors (oestrogens tend to enhance B lymphocyte proliferation and antibody production, whereas androgens usually act as immunosuppressants) and genetic factors linked to the X chromosome (which concentrates numerous genes related to innate and adaptive immunity).
- a) Formulate a justified hypothesis to predict whether males with Klinefelter syndrome (47,XXY karyotype) will have a risk of developing SLE more similar to that of 46,XY males or to that of 46,XX females.
- b) From an adaptive perspective, a more vigorous humoral immune response in females confers greater resistance against bacterial and viral infections. Justify how this evolutionary advantage can translate, under certain genetic and environmental conditions, into an unfavourable cost in the form of autoimmune disease.
- c) A primary care physician attends to a young male with symmetrical joint pain, malar rash, and positive antinuclear antibodies (ANA), but rules out the diagnosis of SLE, stating that "lupus is a disease exclusive to women." Refute this medical decision by differentiating between epidemiological probability and clinical diagnostic exclusion.
Immunodeficiencies
Opportunistic microorganisms such as the fungus Pneumocystis jirovecii live alongside us without causing harm, but they can cause life-threatening pneumonia in people whose CD4 T lymphocytes fall below 200 cells per microlitre. What happens in the body when its defences drop their guard against microbes that a healthy system keeps in check every day? We will come back to this at the end of the section.
Back to the start: below 200 CD4 cells per microlitre the immune system can no longer control microbes such as Pneumocystis jirovecii, so a normally harmless fungus causes serious pneumonia.
What is an immunodeficiency? Distinguish between primary and acquired immunodeficiency, and give an example of each type.
What is an immunodeficiency? Distinguish between primary and acquired immunodeficiency, and give an example of each type.
HIV causes AIDS. Explain which cell of the immune system it infects, why the patient's defences weaken over time, and what opportunistic infections are that appear in…
HIV causes AIDS. Explain which cell of the immune system it infects, why the patient's defences weaken over time, and what opportunistic infections are that appear in the final stage.
Pathogens, transmission and the stages of infectious disease
In January, a flu outbreak closes a classroom in a Galway secondary school while a nearby class carries on as normal. A pathogen is any organism or particle that causes disease. How do different pathogens get from one person to another, and how do they replicate once they arrive?
What is an infectious agent or pathogen? Classify the main types (viruses, bacteria, fungi, protozoa) and give an example of a disease caused by each one.
What is an infectious agent or pathogen? Classify the main types (viruses, bacteria, fungi, protozoa) and give an example of a disease caused by each one.
What is contagion? Describe two routes of transmission of pathogens (respiratory, digestive, by contact, by vectors or sexual and blood-borne) and one effective…
What is contagion? Describe two routes of transmission of pathogens (respiratory, digestive, by contact, by vectors or sexual and blood-borne) and one effective prevention measure for each.
Put the stages of an infectious disease in order (convalescence period, incubation, acute phase, decline) and briefly describe what occurs in each.
Put the stages of an infectious disease in order (convalescence period, incubation, acute phase, decline) and briefly describe what occurs in each.
Antibiotics cure bacterial infections but not viral ones. Explain why (viruses use the machinery of our cells and lack targets such as the cell wall), reason why the…
Antibiotics cure bacterial infections but not viral ones. Explain why (viruses use the machinery of our cells and lack targets such as the cell wall), reason why the abuse of antibiotics selects resistant bacteria and explain what antibiotic resistance means as a public health problem.
Unit challenge. Imagine you are advising your school's health committee. Your mission is to assess your community's immune status against respiratory viruses and prepare…
Unit challenge. Imagine you are advising your school's health committee. Your mission is to assess your community's immune status against respiratory viruses and prepare a reasoned technical report.
-
Data collection: Consult the latest respiratory virus surveillance report on the website of the Health Protection Surveillance Centre (HPSC) or survey $10$ people around you about their flu vaccination to verify whether the target coverage of $75.0$ % is reached.
-
Immunological analysis: Design a comparative table distinguishing the innate versus specific immune mechanisms activated by the pathogen, classifying the type of immunity conferred by the vaccine (natural/artificial, active/passive).
-
Study of pathologies: Justify how the body would respond if the individual had a congenital immunodeficiency or experienced a hypersensitivity reaction to the inoculated antigen.
-
Final proposal: Write a one-page reasoned proposal with preventive measures to optimize herd immunity and safeguard individuals with immune disorders.
Assessment criteria:
-
Accuracy in differentiating the cellular and molecular components of innate and specific immunity.
-
Rigour in classifying the types of immunity and explaining immunological memory.
-
Biological consistency when analyzing the proposed immune pathologies.
-
Communicative clarity and scientific basis in community health proposals.
The hygiene hypothesis and the balance of the immune system
Throughout the 20th century, while vaccines (such as the HSE childhood immunisation schedule), running water and antibiotics sent mortality from childhood infections in Irish cities plummeting, rates of asthma and allergic dermatitis rose several-fold. Is it possible that a lack of exposure to microbes in the first years of life disorients the immune system and prevents it from maturing in a balanced way?
Back to the start: children with fewer early microbial encounters may develop an immune system tilted towards allergic responses.
Excessive hygiene during childhood has been related to the increase of allergies in developed countries (the hygiene hypothesis). Explain briefly what this hypothesis…
Excessive hygiene during childhood has been related to the increase of allergies in developed countries (the hygiene hypothesis). Explain briefly what this hypothesis consists of.
Coeliac disease is an immune reaction to gluten that damages the mucosa of the small intestine. Explain why it is not considered a classic food allergy (T lymphocytes…
Coeliac disease is an immune reaction to gluten that damages the mucosa of the small intestine. Explain why it is not considered a classic food allergy (T lymphocytes and autoantibodies are involved, with an autoimmune component) and what its only effective treatment is today.
Transplants between identical twins barely need immunosuppression, while those performed between unrelated people do. Explain what determines that difference (identity…
Transplants between identical twins barely need immunosuppression, while those performed between unrelated people do. Explain what determines that difference (identity of the HLA or MHC markers) and what the histocompatibility test performed before a transplant consists of.
A woman with a severe allergy to wasp venom begins specific immunotherapy treatment (increasing subcutaneous doses of venom administered periodically over 3 years).…
A woman with a severe allergy to wasp venom begins specific immunotherapy treatment (increasing subcutaneous doses of venom administered periodically over 3 years). Throughout the therapy, her tests show a notable increase in regulatory T lymphocytes (Treg) producing IL-10 and TGF-β, a significant increase in specific IgG4 antibodies, and a slight decrease in the concentration of specific IgE. After two years of treatment, she suffers an accidental sting in the countryside and shows no anaphylactic symptoms.
- a) Interpret the mechanism by which induced Treg lymphocytes suppress the allergic response, indicating on which lymphocyte populations (Th2) and effector cells (mast cells and basophils) they exert their immunomodulatory action.
- b) Reason how IgG4 antibodies act as "blocking antibodies": why does their binding to wasp venom prevent massive mast cell degranulation even though the patient still retains IgE molecules bound in her body?
- c) If, due to medical error, a high dose of allergen were administered to the patient from the first day of treatment instead of following a progressive scaling of tiny concentrations over months, predict what immediate immunological response would be triggered and justify why the gradual dose increase is indispensable for inducing tolerance.
An epidemiological study compared the prevalence of allergic diseases between children raised on traditional farms (Group A), where they interact daily with livestock…
An epidemiological study compared the prevalence of allergic diseases between children raised on traditional farms (Group A), where they interact daily with livestock and soils rich in microbial endotoxins, and children raised in urban centre apartments (Group B) with strict domestic disinfection routines and scarce contact with animals. The incidence of allergic asthma in Group B was 14.2%, compared to only 2.8% in Group A.
- a) Interpret these results drawing upon the "hygiene hypothesis": explain how early exposure to a wide microbial diversity modulates the balance between T helper lymphocyte subpopulations (Th1 versus Th2) and the activity of regulatory T lymphocytes (Treg).
- b) A detergent company promotes a cleaner with the slogan: "Kills 99.9% of bacteria to keep your children allergy-free." Based on immunological foundations, refute the premise of this commercial slogan in a justified manner.
- c) Does it follow from the hygiene hypothesis that water purification or the vaccination schedule should be abolished to strengthen the infant immune system? Justify your answer by distinguishing between exposure to non-pathogenic commensal environmental microorganisms and exposure to lethal virulent pathogens.